25 Best Mascaras for Every Lash Look in 2025

Chanel LE VOLUME gives luxe, noticeable volume and length, and in our testing lashes looked fuller with a polished finish. Our experience shows the formula is on the wetter side, which can cause lashes to lose curl and occasionally clump if you apply multiple coats. Priced at $40 with a 7.5/10 score, it's a splurge for volume lovers who prioritize dramatic impact over waterproof wear and perfect curl retention.

Lancôme Monsieur Big delivers the hyper-full volume the name promises — in our testing lashes appeared dramatically thicker and more prominent. However, the large brush and thick formula make precise application tricky, and layering often leads to clumping and harder removal, which contributed to its 6.5/10 score. If you want bold, camera-ready volume at around $16 and don't mind extra cleanup time, this is a go-to; otherwise consider a more precise wand for everyday wear.

KUSH High Volumizing gives your lashes noticeable fullness and conditioning thanks to hemp-derived cannabis seed oil, and in our experience lashes felt softer after wear. Despite its vegan, gluten-free, cruelty-free credentials, the formula can feel heavy, clump with additional coats, and some users reported smudging or flaking during the day. It scored a 6/10 in our testing — a tempting option for conditioning and volume, but expect a bit more maintenance and careful removal.

Dark Star Mascara brings bold volume that visibly thickens lashes, and in our testing it added striking definition for evening looks. We found the payoff is impressive up front, but the formula struggled with clumping and flaking over wear, which hurt the all-day reliability. The oversized brush can make precise application difficult for smaller eyes, so during our review this one scored a 6/10 — great for short outings but not the best daily workhorse.

If you crave instant fullness, Fullest Volumizing Mascara makes lashes look dramatically thicker — in our testing it delivered impressive volume that reads well in photos and low-light. We found the formula can flake during wear, and the large brush may be tricky for smaller eye shapes, which combined with a higher price dragged the score to 6.5/10. During our review it defined lashes nicely without adding length, but frequent touch-ups may erode its everyday appeal.

Too Faced Better Than Sex delivers the dramatic volume and length its name promises — in our testing lashes looked visibly thicker and more extended, which is why it earned a high 8.5/10. We found the hourglass brush builds impactful volume, but the formula can flake onto the under-eye area within hours and may smudge for some wearers, so keep blotting tissues handy. During our review it performed best when paired with an eyelash curler and careful application to minimize fallout.

YSL's LASH CLASH EXTREME VOLUME delivers show-stopping drama fast — during our review one coat created noticeable lift and curl without visible clumps. We found the formula excels at creating an instant eye-opening effect, but our experience shows results can be inconsistent: some users report it doesn’t add as much volume as promised. Also expect to spend extra time at night, as removal can be stubborn and may require multiple cleansers. With a 7.5/10 score and $33 price, it's best for bold looks.

Badgal BANG! by Benefit is one of our favorites for dramatic, photo-ready lashes — in our testing it delivered impressive volume without clumping and felt lightweight enough to wear all day. We found the flexible brush makes precise application easy, so you can build impact without flaking. That said, during our review the wet formula occasionally transferred onto eyelids and some wearers reported smudging after extended hours, and the shiny packaging attracts fingerprints. At $27 and an 8.5/10, it’s a top performer.

L'Oreal Voluminous Panorama is a wallet-friendly option that amps up lash pigment — in our testing the rich black shade instantly defined eyes and made lashes read darker in photos. We found it separates well for definition, but during our review it can clump if you swipe too aggressively and doesn't always hold curl on straighter lashes. At around $12.39 and a 7/10 score, this is a strong budget pick when you want bold color and length without breaking the bank, just mind your application.

Clinique Lash Power is a dependable option for natural, long-wearing looks — our review found it resists flaking and smudging through sweat, humidity, and tears. The thin brush catches every lash and separates while providing believable length, so lashes look defined without heavy volume. We did note removal can be stubborn even with makeup remover, and the finish is understated; at $27 and a 7.5/10, it's ideal when durability matters more than dramatic impact.

The non-waterproof Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High is a standout drugstore lengthener — during our review it delivered clear, noticeable length while maintaining natural curl. The flexible wand reaches tiny corner lashes and the lightweight formula avoids weighing lashes down, though some wearers experience flaking after several hours. At $9.99 and an 8.5/10 score, it's excellent everyday value if you prioritize length and curl retention over heavy volume and long-term waterproof resilience.

As a splurge-worthy volumizer, Diorshow Iconic Overcurl delivers impressive volume, length and curl with just one coat — in our testing the curved brush really lifts lashes for an eye-opening effect. We found the formula is long-lasting with minimal flaking or smudging, but it's not waterproof and can be tricky to remove completely. During our review multiple coats tended to clump, and the large curved wand can make lower-lash application fiddly. At a 7.5/10 it's great for dramatic daytime looks if you value curl over fuss-free removal.

The Tarte tartelette Tubing Mascara is a solid lengthener that shines when you want long, separated lashes and fuss-free removal — in our testing it rinses off easily with warm water thanks to its tubing action. We found it contains nourishing ingredients like shea butter and castor oil that keep lashes feeling conditioned, but it doesn't build much volume and some users reported flaking after several hours. During our review it scored a 7/10: reliable for everyday length but not the best choice if you need heavy volume or waterproof wear.

Benefit Roller Lash is one of our favorite curlers for everyday wear — in our testing the Hook ’n’ Roll™ brush caught, separated and curled each lash for defined, fluttery results. We found the formula is water-resistant and durable against tears and humidity, earning it an 8/10 for reliable curl and separation. That said, some wearers with oily skin or hooded lids reported smudging and transfer, and it won't deliver dramatic volume if thickness is your top priority.

Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions promises the look of longer, naturally thicker lashes while supporting lash health — in our testing the formula felt conditioning and kept lashes flexible with a visibly extended effect. We found it markets itself as a waterproof option that helps hold curl all day, but in practice it can feel heavy and may clump if layered too much. During our review it earned a 6/10: a good pick for lash care and length, albeit pricier and slightly high-maintenance.

Charlotte Tilbury's Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! mascara lifts and curls with ease — in our testing it delivered a noticeable lift that brightened eyes and layered well for a sultry finish. We found the unique wand gives great separation when you master the technique, but it takes practice and excess product can cause clumping. During our review it scored a 7/10: a lovely option for a lifted, defined look, just be patient with the wand to avoid overapplication.

ILIA Limitless Lash gives you a customizable build thanks to its dual-sided brush that lets you dial volume or length on demand — in our testing that flexibility is its biggest perk. We found the formula holds curl and resists flaking throughout the day, so lashes look polished without constant touch-ups. Be aware the mascara dries quickly, which can make layering fiddly, and some users reported eye irritation after prolonged wear. At a 7/10 score and $29, it's a smart mid-range pick if you like control.

Glossier's Lash Slick is perfect if you want a subtle, natural finish — in our testing the lightweight formula lengthened and defined lashes without feeling heavy. We found that while it creates a believable daytime look, the curl can fall flat after a few hours and it isn't waterproof, so watery eyes may lead to smudging. During our review it scored a 6.5/10: great for minimal makeup days, but keep a curler and touch-up plan handy if you need all-day lift.

If you want curl that lasts, Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof held lift impressively during our testing and kept lashes defined through the day. We found the hourglass brush can make application fiddly and the formula tends to flake or smudge for some users, which hurt its 6.5/10 score. The mascara does deliver noticeable volume and length, but our experience shows you'll need patience with application and cleanup — bring a reliable remover for touch-ups at $16.

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof delivers noticeable length and lightweight lift — in our testing it adds volume without clumping and stays put thanks to its waterproof formula. We found the bamboo extract keeps lashes flexible and natural-feeling, but removal is a hassle; even dedicated makeup removers struggled to dissolve the formula cleanly. At about $8.32 and an 8/10 score, this is a strong value pick if you can tolerate extra removal time and a somewhat flimsy-feeling wand.

Clinique High Impact Waterproof gives clean definition and a featherlight finish that, during our review, didn't leave lashes stiff — it earned a respectable 7/10 for reliability. We found it lengthens well and resists flaking, making it a dependable choice for days you need waterproof performance. That said, significant clumping during application and modest curl hold (especially on straight lashes) mean you'll need careful layering to get the volumizing results some expect at $27.

Lancôme Définicils Waterproof stood out in our testing, earning a 9/10 for its exceptional separation and long-lasting, smudge-proof wear. We found it lengthens without clumping and creates clean, defined lashes — a great pick if you want precision more than bulk. Keep in mind some users report the tube dries out quickly and it can be stubborn to remove without an oil-based cleanser; if longevity and crisp definition matter most, this $34 mascara is hard to beat.

M·A·CStack Waterproof gives buildable volume and length while staying clump-free in our hands, and its ophthalmologist-tested formula is friendly for contact lens wearers. In our testing the formula can feel wet at first, which may reduce curl and invite clumping if you rush between coats. Some testers also reported it was harder to remove, but at $20.30 and a 7/10 score it's a solid, buildable waterproof option if you pace your application and allow drying time between layers.

Lancôme Lash Idôle Waterproof impressed us in testing with a curved silicone brush that reaches tiny corners and separates lashes cleanly — during our review it held up through humidity and tears without flaking or smudging. We found it's comfortable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, which is a big plus for longevity. That said, it’s pricier and can be stubborn to remove, sometimes clumping if you overapply. At $21 and an 8/10 score, it's a durable, high-performing waterproof choice.

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Waterproof is a go-to if you have sensitive eyes — in our testing it provided natural-looking volume and clean definition without clumping or irritation. We found the formula's waterproof claim held up well for humidity and tears, though some users did notice smudging by the end of a long day. During our review it earned a 7.5/10 for being dependable and gentle: it won't create dramatic length but it's a smart pick when comfort and reliable wear matter most.