Choosing a Secure Package Delivery Box for Worry-Free Deliveries

During our review, the dVault DVCS0023 impressed with heavy-duty 16-gauge galvanized steel and a removable tote that makes retrieval fast and organized. As a freestanding unit, it's built for serious security, but maximum package size is roughly 16.9 x 9.25 x 12 inches, so bulky boxes may not fit. Installation is substantial - its weight and need for a concrete pad or pedestal add time and cost. At $949 and an 8/10, it's a premium, high-security choice if your deliveries fit the size envelope.

Our top-rated choice at 9.5/10, the Elephantrunk impressed us with its cast aluminum and powder‑coated steel build, pry‑resistant 3‑point keyed lock, and rotating drum that swallows multiple large parcels securely. During our review, proper leveling and secure bolting were key—this unit is heavy and may benefit from concrete or a sturdy base. It isn’t USPS‑approved for mail, but for parcels it delivered the best blend of capacity and security we tested, justifying the $264.99 price for most homeowners.

We found the Mail Boss Package Master hits a sweet balance of protection and price, earning an 8.5/10 for most households. Heavy-gauge galvanized steel and a weather-resistant post-mount build feel rock solid, the roomy interior handled several days of mail and small parcels, and the high-security keyed lock includes three laser-cut keys. Downsides: it's heavy to install, the proprietary lock can be tricky to service, and the deposit chute may jam if overfilled. At $248.50, it's a standout value compared with pricier vaults.

Those wanting a roomy, low-maintenance solution will appreciate the Step2 Lakewood's double-wall resin build and included keyed lock, which handled everyday weather well in our testing. We fit a variety of common packages inside, but it isn't fully theft-proof - determined intruders can lift or reach under the lid if it's not anchored. Assembly takes time, and you'll need to weight or anchor the base yourself. At $219.99 and a 6.5/10, it's a solid midrange pick for lower-risk porches.

Looking to keep deliveries simple on a budget? In our testing, the Keter Package Delivery Box (6/10) proved easy for couriers thanks to its drop-box design and padlock-compatible hasp, and the hidden bottom chamber lets you add weight or anchor it for stability. Just know its plastic/resin build is fairly light, weather‑resistant but not heavy-duty, and it can’t accept oversized boxes—so plan on standard parcels and consider securing it to the ground for better outdoor performance. At $182.69, it’s a practical starter solution, just not a fortress.

Built for everyday security, the Qualarc WF-PB003's heavy-gauge galvanized steel and powder-coat finish stood up well to weather in our testing. The keyed lock keeps retrieval controlled, and its freestanding design can be bolted to the ground for welcome stability. That said, we found the drop mechanism feels thinner than the body, mounting hardware often isn't included, and some drivers still leave boxes on top. At $434.99 and a 7/10, it's a solid mid-tier pick if you'll handle hardware and coach delivery habits.

For maximum physical protection, The Vault XXL scored 8.5/10 in our testing thanks to its 1/4-inch hand‑welded steel body and Vault Lock Extreme with a Medeco lock—about as tough as residential parcel lockers get. It’s powder‑coated inside and out for weather resilience, but the 325‑lb weight and post‑mount installation typically require professional help. At $2,145, it’s a premium solution with a limited ~6‑inch internal height, best suited for frequent small, high‑value deliveries rather than bulky boxes.

The Step2 Express is the cheapest way we found to corral deliveries, earning 4.5/10 for its weather‑resistant resin build and surprisingly spacious interior. However, with no built‑in lock and a lightweight design that can be moved or tipped, it’s purely a convenience bin—not true security. At $59.99, it’s fine in low‑risk areas or paired with a camera, but for theft‑prone porches we’d upgrade to a locking, anchorable box. Freestanding placement is easy, but anchoring or added weight is advisable.

For compact wall spaces, the QualArc Sentry Junior's heavy-gauge galvanized steel and powder-coat finish felt durable during our review. Its top-loading slot drops envelopes and small parcels into a locked compartment, but the butterfly-style keyed lock is basic and capacity is limited - larger deliveries won't fit. Plan to purchase mounting hardware separately and set aside time for installation. At $199.99 and a 5/10, it's best for light mail and small-package scenarios rather than a full-scale package solution.

If you need a durable locking mailbox with light parcel capability, the Oasis earned a 6/10 in our testing for its heavy‑gauge galvanized steel body and convenient front/rear doors. The keyed locking access helps deter casual theft, though capacity is modest compared to dedicated parcel boxes. Be prepared to source a compatible post or mounting bracket separately, and note that replacing the cam/key cylinder can be finicky—trade‑offs that keep the $99.78 price attractive but the overall score mid‑pack.

On a tight budget or short on space, the VEVOR wall-mount box offers a compact, waterproof option that worked well for small parcels in our testing. The galvanized steel body and anti-theft internal baffle help deter fishing, and the wall mount keeps your porch clear. However, the coded combination lock isn't as robust as heavy-duty keyed mechanisms, capacity is modest, and some users report wear to seals over heavy use. At $93.99 and a 5.5/10, it's best for low-risk, light-duty drops.

Among value picks, the Clevermade S100 Series earned a 7/10 in our review for its reinforced galvanized steel body, built‑in lock with programmable keypad, and included anchor screws that make ground‑bolting straightforward. We did encounter occasional keypad finickiness and found sealing around the lid can allow some water or debris in, so pick a semi‑sheltered spot if possible. Installation into concrete or masonry takes the right tools, but at $148.45 it’s a strong, budget‑friendly step up in physical security.

If you just need an ultra‑budget, indoor drop box, the BARSKA scored 4.5/10 in our review for its compact wall‑mount footprint and included keys and hardware. Our experience shows its thin galvanized steel and basic keyed mechanism are vulnerable to prying, and it’s not weatherproof—so avoid exterior use. At $30.46 it’s hard to beat on price, but for outdoor package protection or theft‑prone areas, we’d step up to a heavier, weather‑resistant model.

The Danby Smart Mailbox earned 6.5/10 in our testing for its anti‑theft drop slot and sturdy, weather‑resistant plastic body that shrugs off rust. We like that you can bolt it down or add weight for stability, but the top compartment only fits standard parcels (about 15 x 10 x 8 inches), and the 40–50 lb heft makes solo setup tougher. Some legacy smart features have been discontinued, so treat it as a dependable keyed, non‑connected solution at $299.

For app‑forward convenience, the Genie BenchSentry Connect scored 7.5/10 with its automatic re‑locking after each drop, roomy 7‑cu‑ft capacity, and app control with tracking‑code PINs for one‑time access. During our review, assembly took patience and the keypad’s IP43 rating means you should avoid heavy exposure; placing it under an eave helps. It does need a nearby power outlet, but if you can accommodate that, it’s a versatile, smart parcel bench at $359.

Balancing smart control and weather protection, the Yale Smart Delivery Box scored 7.5/10 in our review, offering app control plus an optional keypad and an overlapping lid that sheds rain. You’ll need the included Wi‑Fi bridge for reliable remote access and to stay on top of battery replacements. It’s relatively heavy and bulky, so placement matters for courier usability, but at $264.58 it’s a well‑rounded connected box for homeowners who value flexible access without hardwiring.