Halloween Party Favors Worth Grabbing by the Handful

Nothing sets a movie-night vibe like Orville Redenbacher’s butter popcorn, and our experience shows the mini bags are clutch for party favors or trick-or-treat packs. The buttery flavor is a crowd-pleaser, though we’ve seen uneven popping and some greasy leaks from bags, so microwave on a plate and watch the timer. A few users reported sparking with certain microwaves—follow directions closely. At $4.78 and widely available, it’s an easy win with a little extra care during popping.

$4.78

at Walmart

Play-Doh Party Bags are an easy crowd-pleaser for Halloween tables, and in our testing the one-ounce cans were perfect for goody bags and on-the-go play. We loved that each mini can comes with a gift tag/sticker, which made labeling and party presentation a snap. Do note that lids can be tough for little hands and the dough dries out if not sealed firmly, so plan a quick adult assist. At $9.99, recent price bumps sting a bit, but the portability and convenience deliver.

$9.99

at Michaels

These Goldfish Colors Cheddar crackers add instant festivity to favor bags, and in our testing kids loved the bright hues. Parents appreciate that the colors come from plant-based extracts, and the 2 oz single-serve cartons are perfect for handouts. Some tasters noticed a slight flavor shift from original cheddar and a bit more saltiness, so pair with water. At $1.49 from Target, it’s an easy, affordable snack—just check freshness dates to avoid the occasional stale or discolored batch.

$1.49

at Target

If you want a reliable glow for the whole night, Cyalume’s green sticks impressed us during our review with 8–12 hours of steady brightness. They’re durable, waterproof, and non-toxic, so they pull double duty for spooky ambience and basic safety marking outdoors. Just know they’re not as bright as a flashlight and single-use creates waste, so reserve them for when reliability matters. At $28, value lags cheaper novelty packs, but we found performance and toughness to be notably better.

$28.00

at Adorama

For big crowds, Syncfun’s 300-piece glow stick set is a value win, and in our testing the 10–14 hour glow kept festivities lit well past bedtime. The included 300 connectors make bracelets and necklaces easy to assemble, though younger kids may need help. We did see some variability in brightness and a few reports of scuffed packaging, so inspect on arrival and pre-sort the best sticks. At $19.99, it’s hard to beat for mass giveaways and spooky group photos.

$19.99

at Walmart

This glow-in-the-dark Silly Putty charges under light and then shines during lights-out games—kids loved the reveal in our testing. The reusable egg snaps shut for easy favor-bag packing, and the non-toxic formula is suitable for ages 4 and up. Keep it out of hot cars, where it can soften or melt, and expect it to attract lint and dirt with heavy outdoor play. Single-egg portions are small, but they’re perfectly sized for economical party bundles.

$1.97

at Thriftywhite

Turn out the lights and these 40-piece LED finger lights bring instant party magic, with bright colors and elastic bands that help them stay put. In our testing, battery life was solid for an evening event, though a few units can arrive DOA or fade early. Be mindful of the small button batteries—serious ingestion hazards—so supervise younger kids and keep spares secured. Compared with glow sticks, these are reusable until the batteries die, though the fit can feel loose for some.

$11.95

at Walmart

Looking for tattoos that don’t feel throwaway? Tattly’s Spooky Squad set stood out in our testing with artist-designed graphics that actually feel special. They’re printed with vegetable-based ink, non-toxic and FDA-compliant, and typically last 2–4 days on low-motion skin, though hands and knuckles fade faster. Application takes a steady hand—intricate minis can mis-transfer—so press firmly and peel slowly, and while $15 is pricier than generic sheets, the upscale look makes party photos and favor bags pop.

$15.00

at Tattly

These authentic vintage Mrs. Grossman skeleton stickers hit the nostalgia sweet spot and, at $4.50 for three sheets, make budget-friendly favors or craft table fodder. During our review, we found they stick great to paper and invites, but they’re not vinyl or weatherproof, so skip water bottles or outdoor gear. As vintage stock, some backing may show mild yellowing or wear, and quantities per listing are limited. For larger parties, plan to buy multiple packs to cover everyone.

$4.50

at Etsy

Need a non-candy handout that actually lasts? This 144-piece Halloween pencil assortment is perfect for classrooms, party bowls, or trick-or-treaters, and in our testing kids loved the spooky, kid-friendly prints. Shipping has been reliably fast, but our experience shows quality can vary—occasional pencils arrive with loose or wrinkled wraps or even missing erasers. Note the California Proposition 65 warning for potential lead exposure. Compared with candy, these are practical favors that see real use long after the party.

$22.98

at Halloweenexpress

Leaning into spooky style, these Savvi Gothic temporary tattoos use skin-safe, cosmetic-grade ink and even include remover wipes for quick cleanup. In our testing, application took patience and some designs wore off after washing or a day’s play, and package variety didn’t always perfectly match photos. That said, they’re made in the USA and the included wipes make swaps between looks painless. For high-impact, short-term flair at a Halloween party, they’re a fun pick—just manage expectations on longevity.

$11.99

at Walmart

For a quiet, pocketable favor, the Tangle Crush is easy to toss in goodie bags and great for restless hands. During our review, the textured segments offered satisfying tactile feedback that helped kids focus without mess, though finishes on metallic versions may rub off over time. The plastic connectors can wear or snap with heavy use, and it’s a choking hazard for children under 3. Compared with slime or putty, it’s cleaner and more classroom-friendly at an easy-to-stretch price.

$6.00

at Rainbowresource

Nothing gets a Halloween parade going like a chorus of kazoos, and the Kazoobie Kazoogle is loud, durable, and easy to hand out. In our experience, the waterproof polyethylene membrane cleans up without fuss, though it will eventually change tone with wear. Colors may vary from photos and plastic won’t match the rich timbre of metal models, but the price and sturdiness are hard to beat. For group games or noisy send-offs, these hit the fun-per-dollar sweet spot.

$5.36

at Kazoos

This mini I-Color football turns favors into an activity: kids color the panels with the included 10 markers, then head outside for a toss. Our experience shows younger players love the soft, machine-stitched feel and compact size, though older kids may find it too small and the markers a bit muted on the white panels. It’s not designed for rough, organized play. Compared with regular mini balls, the personalization factor steals the show for craft-friendly Halloween gatherings.

$19.99

at Franklinsports

Mini UNO decks are a quirky, budget-friendly favor, and during our review we found them easy to toss into any party bag or purse. At just $0.99, they’re great for bulk buys, decorations, or little game prizes, but the tiny cards can be hard to shuffle and handle. Quality and authenticity can vary from third-party sellers like AliExpress, so temper expectations. Because of the very small pieces, we don’t recommend these for very young kids or unsupervised play.

$0.99

at Aliexpress

Teenie Swirl NeeDohs are the kind of fidget toy kids immediately pocket, and in our experience they’re perfect for grab bags. The squishy, satisfying feel holds up to lots of squeezing, though prints and lettering tend to wear off quickly. Some units can be a bit sticky or even leak, and they pick up lint, so we like to bag them individually. At $5.97, it’s an affordable tactile favor—just supervise heavy use and give them a quick wipe now and then.

$5.97

at Walmart

These Melissa & Doug Scratch Art Rainbow Mini Notes make a simple, hit activity station, and during our review the dispenser box kept the 125-card stack tidy. Kids love scratching designs with the included stylus, though it’s small and easy to misplace—bring extras if you’re hosting a group. The mini size is thinner and smaller than some expect, and many cards skew blue in color. At $12.70, you get plenty of favors without breaking the budget.

$12.70

at Walmart

Crayola Model Magic is our go-to for low-mess crafting, and in our testing the lightweight, air-drying compound was easy for little hands to shape. You can reuse leftovers if you store them airtight, and the bright colors (like red and blue) pop in tiny projects. Be aware of occasional color transfer or inconsistent texture, and the individual portions are small for big groups. At $8.99, it’s a versatile, non-toxic pick for ages 3+ with a few planning tweaks.

$8.99

at Target