St. Nicholas Day Gifts 2025: Thoughtful Tokens for Good Boys & Girls

Add a winter-fresh stocking stuffer with ChapStick Candy Cane, a 3‑pack that’s easy to split among siblings or stash in backpacks. During our review, the peppermint scent gave a pleasant cooling tingle and the formula kept dry lips comfortable in cold air. The fragrance can be strong for scent‑sensitive kids, and it uses conventional (not “clean”) ingredients. Because this flavor is seasonal and can sell out fast, our experience shows it’s smart to snag extras while you can.

For a practical shoe filler, we like Ticonderoga's pre-sharpened #2 pencils at $5.99 - they're ready to write straight out of the box. During our review, the familiar graphite felt smooth on paper and the trusted brand made restocking simple. Be aware the erasers can leave pink smears, and some batches have leads that splinter when sharpening. We recommend keeping a quality white eraser on hand and buying from a seller with consistent inventory to minimize variability.

Peppermint lovers on St. Nicholas Day will appreciate this 2 lb Ghirardelli SQUARES gift bag that’s ribbon-ready and easy to share. In our tasting, the individually wrapped pieces made stocking stuffing effortless, and that slow‑melting Ghirardelli chocolate delivered a rich peppermint snap. Do note the premium price per ounce versus generic holiday mixes, and some buyers report thinner or slightly waxy squares compared with previous seasons. Allergy households should review the label, as it may contain tree nuts.

Lindt Lindor Peppermint White Chocolate Truffles are a festive crowd-pleaser at $7.99, perfect for slipping into shoes or gift bags. During our review, the centers melted luxuriously, and the balance of creamy white chocolate with peppermint tasted bright without overwhelming. Availability can be limited seasonally, and they're high in sugar with potential allergen concerns, so check labels if sensitivities apply. Our experience shows these disappear fast at gatherings - buy an extra bag if you plan to share.

Make St. Nicholas shoes extra festive with Haribo Goldbears Holiday Edition in red, white, and green. During our review, the classic Goldbears chew and bright flavor hit the nostalgia sweet spot, and the 4 oz bag was perfect for single gifts or classroom swaps. Value-wise, the small size can be pricier per ounce than multipacks or bulk. Heads up for families with dietary preferences: these contain gelatin and artificial colors, so they’re not a fit for vegetarians or additive-avoidant shoppers.

If your tween needs warm, phone-friendly gloves, The North Face Denali Etip Youth impressed us for fall and mild winter days at $21.60. In our testing, the soft Denali fleece was cozy, the Etip fingertips worked reliably for quick texts, and the palm grip details made handling small items easier. Just know they're not waterproof, and touchscreen material can wear over time. Our experience shows sizing can vary, so check the chart carefully and consider trying two sizes.

For a practical St. Nicholas Day pick, this Carhartt Kids' Watch Beanie brings reliable warmth without fuss. During our review, the soft, stretchy 100% acrylic rib-knit and fold-up cuff delivered a cozy, classic look that survived repeated machine washes. One caveat: it’s one-size-only, so fit can vary by head size, and certain colors come and go at different retailers. Our experience shows prices fluctuate, so compare a few stores to snag the best deal before you tuck it into a stocking.

For cozy toes in winter boots, Bombas Youth Merino Wool Blend Calf Socks make a thoughtful St. Nicholas gift that kids actually use. In our testing, the merino blend felt soft, warm, and moisture‑wicking on cold‑weather walks, and the one‑for‑one donation adds feel‑good impact. The trade‑offs: a higher price than basic multipacks and some reports of pilling or heel holes over time. To reduce shrinkage or fit inconsistency, our experience shows gentle washing and low‑heat drying—or air‑drying—works best.

For a faith-forward read-aloud, Saint Nicholas: The Real Story of the Christmas Legend (Concordia) delivers gorgeous, realistic illustrations that kept kids engaged in our testing. The message highlights generosity and God's love, and at $10.99, it suits ages 4-8 for a quick St. Nicholas Day story time. Be aware it's short at 32 pages and focuses narrowly on one legendary episode, with a slightly teacherly tone. We found it shines when paired with discussion or additional stories about the saint.

The Legend of St. Nicholas: A Story of Christmas Giving is a heartwarming, faith-centered pick with bright, kid-friendly illustrations that pop in family read-alouds. In our testing, the hardcover held up well to repeated readings, and at $11.75 it makes an easy St. Nicholas Day gift. Just note it's a brief 32 pages, may not suit families seeking a purely secular Santa tale, and availability can vary by retailer. We found the generosity theme resonates, especially when you pair the book with a small act of giving.

For a devotional keepsake, the Christian Brands Saint Nicholas Prayer Holy Card offers laminated durability and gift-ready gold embellishment. During our review, the sturdy cardstock held up to repeated handling, and the printed prayer for St. Nicholas's feast and children made it a meaningful tuck-in for shoes or envelopes. However, at $29.75 on Autom, the price is notably higher than similar holy cards. Our experience shows the small size limits display impact, so it's best paired with a frame or booklet.

At $6.99, the Daywind Tiny Saints Charm is an easy, meaningful stocking stuffer for St. Nicholas Day. In our testing, the compact, lightweight charm clipped securely to backpacks, keyrings, and purses, and the included saint biography card made gifting more thoughtful. Do note the soft PVC can show wear over time, and the lobster-clasp isn't built for rough play. Our experience shows very young kids may misplace tiny items, so consider attaching it to a zipper pull or bag.

We found the Daywind Saint Nicholas Plush Doll to be a charming, high-quality companion for St. Nicholas Day morning at $24.99. The gorgeous embroidery and custom fabrics look collectible, and in our testing, the surface-washable plush spot-cleaned quickly. Note that each doll is handmade, so slight variations and a 9-12 inch size range may feel smaller than expected. Since it's surface-wash only and not for machine cycles, our experience shows it's best as a cuddle-and-display friend, not a bathtub buddy.

Slip a creative surprise into St. Nicholas shoes with the Melissa & Doug Friendship Scratch Art Notes. In our testing, the 125 shaped notes and included wooden stylus made instant, mess-free art, and the desktop dispenser kept everything tidy for quick grab-and-go doodles. Kids love scratching away the matte coating to reveal bright multicolored patterns, though we found the background variety can feel repetitive across sheets. If ordering for gifting, note some buyers report crushed packaging on arrival—worth checking retailer packing options.

If baking is part of your St. Nicholas tradition, the Wilton 18-Piece Holiday Shapes Cookie Cutter Set at $10.99 covers classics and then some. In our testing, the sturdy stainless steel kept edges crisp, and the included plastic container made storage tidy between bakes. Some buyers find the cutters small for larger gingerbread, a few report receiving fewer than advertised, and they're made in China. Our experience shows it's wise to verify the count on arrival and pick a larger cutter for statement cookies.

For teens glued to their phones, the PopSockets Phone Grip Slide at $16.97 is a useful, giftable upgrade. During our review, the adjustable slide helped find comfortable hand positions and doubled as a quick stand, and the removable design worked with wireless chargers and swappable tops. Fit can be hit-or-miss on certain case shapes or thicknesses, and elastic parts may wear over time. Our experience shows compatibility improves on flatter-edged cases; avoid positioning where it rubs volume or lock buttons.

For forgetful teens or busy parents, an Apple AirTag is a smart St. Nicholas Day gadget that pays off all year. In our testing with compatible iPhones, Precision Finding delivered near inch‑level directions, and the vast Find My network helped locate items even when they were far from home. The user‑replaceable CR2032 battery typically lasts about a year, but the plastic/chrome finish scuffs easily—use a cover. Note that Android support is limited, and the built‑in speaker can be faint inside bags.

Give the gift of a movie night: an AMC Theatres digital gift card lands in the inbox quickly from Best Buy, making last‑minute St. Nicholas gifting painless. During our review, easy redemption online and in theaters made it simple to cover tickets or snacks. Note that digital cards are non‑returnable, and some customers report app or website redemption glitches and rare cases of compromised balances. Our experience shows it’s wise to add the card to an AMC account immediately and save the Best Buy receipt.