The Best Bagel Toasters of 2025: Perfectly Crisped Every Time

In our testing, the BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Toaster, priced at $38.99, demonstrated excellent value with its wide slots and variety of settings, scoring 8/10. While it excels with its easy cleaning features, some users may find the toasting performance slightly inconsistent. If you're seeking a compact toaster that combines versatility and ease of maintenance, this could be the perfect fit, with just a slight compromise on toasting precision.

The Oster 2-Slice Toaster is a budget-friendly option, with handy features like extra-wide slots and a bagel function. During our review, however, we noticed uneven toasting and occasional lever issues, which may challenge some users. Scoring 6/10, this toaster offers great value for its price, but be prepared for occasional quirks, such as an initial burning plastic smell.

In our tests, the GE 4-Slice Toaster offered impressive design and ease of use, especially with its wide slots. Despite its reasonable 6.5/10 score, users should be mindful of inconsistent toasting and initial odors, which mar its otherwise strong performance. For those prioritizing form and basic functionality, this toaster provides a decent mid-range option.

The Chefman 2-Slice Toaster impresses with wide slots and a very user-friendly control panel, scoring 6.5/10 in our testing. While the seven browning settings offer customization, users may find that the toaster can over-toast, and uneven results are common. If you're after versatility and ease of use in a compact form, this toast powerhouse might be worth a try, though expect some quirks.

The Holstein Housewares 2-Slice Toaster is a great pick for budget-conscious shoppers seeking simplicity in the kitchen. While its wide slots can accommodate a variety of breads, our tests indicated potential safety concerns with the cover melting after minimal use. Scoring 5.5/10, consider this toaster if you need affordability and compact design, but be mindful of its durability.

This KitchenAid 2 Slice Toaster marries simplicity and utility, with features like a bagel setting and extra-wide slots ideal for those morning bagels. Despite its appealing versatility, our experience shows it toasts more gently, even on high settings, which may not satisfy darker-toast fans. With a 7/10 rating, this high-cost option lacks a countdown timer yet promises stylish durability for those invested in long-term countertop companions.

The KRUPS 4-Slice Toaster stands out in our review with its versatility, thanks to independent control panels and extra-large slots accommodating thick bagels. We found its high-lift lever makes toast retrieval safe, though its large footprint and slower toasting time may not suit all kitchens. Scoring a 7/10, it excels in functionality but watch out for overheating during use, which can pose a burn risk.

The 4-Slice Auto Adjust Toaster intrigued us with its auto-adjust feature, promising perfectly even browning. While its compact design and multiple browning settings are attractive features for those short on space, we noticed an unfortunate lack of detailed reviews and information on additional functions. Priced at $62.39, it's a tempting option for those who prioritize design, though the absence of a crumb tray might deter some users.

While the Retro 2 Slice Toaster boasts stylish aesthetics and customization features, our review pointed out its lower performance scores, with users reporting burning and slow, uneven toasting. Despite its eye-catching design and wide slots, the plastic material may emit an off smell, distracting from the toasting experience. At $39.98, it's best suited for those who value style but can tolerate its quirks.

Elevate your morning routine with the Mecity 4 Slice Toaster, offering ample capacity and a digital countdown for precise control. Our testing praised its extra-wide slots fitting various breads and useful functions like reheat and defrost. However, the bulkiness and occasionally unresponsive touch screen are notable downsides. With an 8/10 score, this toaster is suited for those prioritizing digital convenience despite some safety concerns with exterior heat.

Expand your morning possibilities with the Cuisinart Toaster Oven and Waffle Maker Bundle, blending even cooking and quick results for a versatile kitchen experience. While the bundle tries to offer convenience, our testing revealed difficulties with the unresponsive dial when selecting settings. Scoring a modest 5/10, this bundle is a great fit for those valuing diversified breakfast options over usability perfection, offering a neat solution at an attractive price of $23.74.

During our review of the Mueller 4 Slice Toaster, we appreciated its extra-wide slots that easily handle thick bagels and breads, making it great for families. While it provides good value and effective bagel toasting, it lost points due to its noisiness and tendency to show fingerprints on its stainless steel exterior. For just $35.50, this toaster offers a balance between functionality and affordability, though it's not quiet or entirely smudge-proof.

The Bella 4 Slice Toaster shines with its value at an unbeatable $19.99 and features like extra-wide slots and a bagel setting. However, our experience highlighted usability issues, including an uneven toasting pattern and a problematic lever. While it meets basic needs for toast variety and quantity, it's best for those on a tight budget who are prepared for occasional manual adjustments.

The Proctor Silex 4-Slice Toaster Oven is perfect for small kitchens due to its compact design and versatility in toasting and baking. While convenient, our experience shows manual flipping is often required for even toasting, and the unit’s exterior can get quite hot. Scoring 6/10, it’s a space-saver but may not suit everyone’s needs for perfectly crisped breakfasts.

The Elite Gourmet 4-Slice Toaster offers great value at $34.99, featuring generous slots for thick artisan breads and a warming rack. While the digital countdown timer adds a modern touch, our review noted the uneven toasting and lightweight build as potential drawbacks. Scoring 6.5/10, it's a practical option if you need an economical toaster with a solid feature set, but don't mind occasional inconsistencies in toast color.