The Best Toilet Plungers 2025: Tested and Reviewed

With an 8.5/10 score, the Plunger Toilet Master impressed us with its large bellows design that moves a lot of water per push, clearing routine clogs fast. In our testing, the durable polyethylene body held up well and offered strong value at $15.99, though you'll need to purge trapped air first to prevent splashback. It doesn't include a holder and can struggle with very deep or distant blockages. Compared with our top-rated GT Water Products bellows plunger, it's nearly as powerful but more wallet-friendly.

Our top-rated pick at 9.5/10, the GT Water Products Master Plunger delivered the strongest performance in our testing. Its bellows design pushes far more water per plunge, and the air-relief valve helped control splashback, a confidence booster during messy jobs. The commercial-grade polyethylene body feels built to last, though its taller shape is a bit awkward to store and fit can vary on unusual bowls. Master the technique and you'll out-clear cup and flange competitors, often in fewer strokes.

The NEIKO Toilet Plunger delivers great results with an 8/10 rating, perfect for those dealing with diverse toilet styles. Its tiered cup design ensures a perfect seal and strong suction, with the aluminum handle providing rustproof durability. Some users noted the handle's smooth finish as less comfortable to grip, and a lingering chemical smell on arrival may be off-putting. Nevertheless, this plunger offers excellent performance, especially for homes with larger bathrooms.

OXO's Good Grips Plunger earns a 6.5/10 for its thoughtful, hygienic storage: the self-closing canister hides the plunger and a drip tray catches excess water to protect floors. In our review, the flange cup handled lighter clogs in low-flush toilets, but some users report cup collapse under pressure and a noticeable chemical odor out of the box. At $29.99 it's attractive, yet performance lags behind stronger bellows models. Choose it if tidy storage matters more than brute plunging power.

While the Clorox Toilet Plunger features a handy hideaway caddy to keep your bathroom looking neat, our review found significant issues with its assembly. The plunger tends to disassemble during use, causing frustration. Although it's affordably priced at $12.17, its bulkiness and poor functionality earned it a lower score of 5/10, ranking it lower in our guide.

When tackling stubborn blockages, Luigi's Toilet Plunger stands out with a commendable score of 8/10 for its efficient performance. The accordion-style plastic construction makes it easy to use, though not the most durable option available. Some users noted a less-than-perfect fit around certain bends, but overall, its ease of assembly and effectiveness make it a solid choice for most households, particularly if your toilet design is compatible.

MR.SIGA's plunger-and-brush combo earns a 6/10 for convenience: the included caddy keeps everything tidy and its compact footprint fits tight bathrooms. During our review, the cup-style rubber plunger handled minor clogs and the setup is easy to grab in a hurry. However, several buyers report the materials feel overly plastic and the build quality doesn't match the $21.98 price. If you prioritize discreet storage over maximum plunging power, it's fine, but better performers exist for the money.

Budget-minded and effective, the HDX High-Efficiency Toilet Plunger scored 8/10 in our testing for its flange that seals tightly on low-flow and high-efficiency bowls, and while it's not our top scorer, it punches above its price. The 18-inch non-absorbent plastic handle is lightweight and resists water damage, and at $9.78 it's a smart spare for guest baths. Just know the plastic handle isn't as stout as wood or metal, and the cup can wear with heavy commercial use. No holder is included, so plan your storage.

In our quest for the best, the Beehive Max Hideaway Toilet Plunger emerged as the standout performer with a stellar score of 9.5/10. Its unique beehive-shaped head and robust T-handle make plunging effortless and effective. While some users noted the handle felt less sturdy, the powerful performance and sanitary storage case make it worth its $22.99 price tag.

During our review, the Toilet Plunger from Simplehuman delivered effective plunging action but fell short with issues like rust and aesthetics at its $30.00 price. With a score of 5.5/10, it features a magnetic collar for drip-free transport and a long, narrow flange design ideal for modern toilets. However, some users found its large size and high cost detracted from its overall value.

Budget-friendly without feeling cheap, the Libman Premium Toilet Plunger & Caddy earned a solid 8/10 in our testing, though it's not our top-rated pick. The extended rubber flange forms a reliable seal on many drains, and the included caddy lets the head dry hygienically between uses, an advantage over the Korky 99-4A, which lacks storage. The steel handle adds strength, but if the finish gets scratched it can show wear, and the flange occasionally folds, reducing suction. At $12.99, it's better value than pricier simplehuman options while rivaling NEIKO's performance.

The Korky 99-4A earned a respectable 7/10 for its effectiveness and ease of use, priced at $20.15. Featuring a T-handle for a secure grip and a large cup for a strong seal, it tackles clogs efficiently. However, storage without a caddy proves inconvenient, and its large size may challenge those with limited space.

For those who value convenience, the Mr. Clean Toilet Bowl Brush and Plunger Set combines cleaning essentials into one package. While we found the caddy's non-slip base handy, the plunger's tendency to emit a persistent odor and seating instability in the caddy limited its score to 6/10. Its rubber flange is designed for unclogging efficiently, though some users noted difficulties in creating an effective seal which might not make it the best option for severe blockages.

The Supply Guru Toilet Plunger offers a budget-friendly option at just $8.79. While it features a classic cup design, our experience shows that its flimsy rubber cup may invert during use, undermining its efficiency. Although it’s a wallet-friendly choice, its lower score of 5.5/10 reflects limitations in durability and ease of use. This makes it less ideal for households dealing with frequent clogs in complex plumbing systems.

The Blue Donuts Toilet Brush and Plunger Set combines modern aesthetics with budget-friendly pricing at $37.61. However, its functionality is hampered by a smaller-than-average plunger and weak handles, leading to a score of 5.5/10. While it boasts interchangeable heads for versatile cleaning and an attractive design, these features may not compensate for the performance shortcomings when dealing with more serious clogs.

On paper, the AmazonCommercial Plunger 2-Pack looks convenient: two lightweight cup plungers for $49.99, handy if you want a spare for another bathroom. In practice, our testing and user feedback docked it to 5/10: the cups can invert under pressure, which kills suction and raises splash risk. Several reviewers also report a flimsy feel that doesn't inspire confidence, and there's no holder included. For similar money, sturdier bellows or flange designs deliver far better reliability.

The Toilet Brush and Plunger set offers innovative storage solutions with magnetic holders to keep your bathroom tidy. Scoring 6/10 in our review, its appealing design and decent durability are overshadowed by a high price and less effective performance. While some users noted potential scratching and stiff brush bristles, it remains a practical choice for those valuing organization over exceptional plunging power. Consider your budget and storage preferences when evaluating this mid-tier option.