The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Checked Bag Size for 2025

Despite a 7/10 rating, the American Tourister Stratum 2.0 Spinner Luggage stands out for budget-conscious travelers looking for expandable luggage. We found the spinner wheels provided smooth 360-degree movement, though the lack of a TSA lock is a downside. The hard shell's tendency to scuff over time could impact long-term durability perception, but overall, this luggage offers a practical, affordable option for those seeking extra space on a budget.

The CLASSIC Check-In M, although on the pricier side at $1,750.00, features a high-end multi-wheel system for stable steering and a telescopic handle with seamless adjustability. Scoring 5.5/10, it offers stability and style through its durable aluminum build and hand-stitched leather accents. However, its relatively high weight and cost may not align with everyone's travel budget, so consider this piece if luxury and quality outweigh your concerns about weight and expense.

The Check-In Icing stands out with an impressive 8/10 score because of its durable polycarbonate shell and smooth, quiet wheels. Although lighter colors tend to scuff and handle placement could cause accidental retraction, the suitcase's interior features like compression straps and dividers offer organized packing. If maneuverability and durability are top priorities for your travels, this might be your go-to choice despite minor concerns around aesthetics and handle functionality.

Although scoring 6/10, the Rockland Melbourne Carry-On is recognized for its budget-friendly price and lightweight design. We found it easy to carry and maneuver, yet there are significant durability concerns, including reports of broken wheels and handles. If affordability and a lightweight build meet your needs, this expandable carry-on offers basic functionality with some trade-offs in longeivity and structural integrity.

While the Expandable Spinner scores impressively at 8.5/10, it comes with a higher price tag and some weight due to its durable nylon build. We found the exterior-mounted handle to significantly improve packing efficiency, a notable advantage for seasoned travelers. If you're seeking a suitcase with longevity and expansive space, this option justifies its premium cost despite weighing more than others.

Travelers seeking reliability and ample packing space will appreciate the Medium Expandable Spinner, which scored an impressive 9/10. This premium suitcase features a high-strength nylon construction with innovative CX® technology, letting you expand your packing capacity effortlessly. Despite its weight, which can be cumbersome, its durability and lifetime warranty make it a favorite for long-haul journeys. While the price might seem high, the quality and reliable construction justify the investment for frequent travelers.

During our review of the SwissGear Sion Luggage, we appreciated the expandable design and organizational features that facilitate efficient packing. The durable polyester fabric can handle rough handling, though the wheels' potential to become unstable after extended use is a downside. With a score of 6.5/10, this option suits travelers valuing thoughtful organization, but beware of its less protective softside design compared to hardside alternatives.

The Ambeur Medium, scoring 7.5/10, is lightweight and ideal for travelers seeking expandable packing space. In our testing, its smooth maneuverability across surfaces stood out, though users noted the glossy exterior's susceptibility to scratches. While the expandable section offers flexibility, its durability might not match that of the hardshell. If you prioritize lightweight ease and packing versatility with some trade-offs on exterior resilience, this suitcase is worth considering.

The Copilot Luggage Roller from Timbuk2, scoring 6.5/10, offers a rugged nylon construction with skateboard wheels that glide effortlessly. However, its heavier weight and subpar main zipper can be concerns for some travelers, as noted in our testing. While it doesn't rank among the top, its high durability is commendable, making this a viable option if you can overlook the zipper issue.

Travel light and smart with the Maxlite 5 Check-In Spinner, boasting a 7/10 rating for its impressive lightweight design. We found its polyester fabric with DuraGuard® coating reliably resisted water and stains, although keeping organized inside may require extra accessories. If you're willing to tackle its organizational challenges, this is a great choice for those who prioritize easy handling and ample space.

The Jet Black Trunk earned a 7.5/10 for its lightweight yet tough design, perfect for those who need additional capacity without compromising durability. The spacious interior makes it easy to overpack, potentially hitting airline weight limits. Despite its higher price, we found it offers a smooth glide with its reliable wheels and robust construction, though it's a bit pricier than similar options.

The Samsonite Winfield 2 Luggage Set, rated 5.5/10, serves as an affordable entry-point for travelers prioritizing lightweight builds. We appreciated the impact-resistant polycarbonate shell, although scratching and handle sturdiness remain concerns. With its smooth 360-degree wheels, it's practical for less rigorous use, while its lack of exterior pockets is a minor inconvenience for frequent access to essentials.

If you're looking for an affordable option, the Rockland Melbourne 28" Spinner Luggage is a decent choice for the budget-conscious traveler. Its lightweight polycarbonate design and smooth spinner wheels make it easy to maneuver across various terrains, and the expandable feature is perfect for packing extra items. However, in our testing, we noted some durability concerns, such as shell cracking and a finicky telescopic handle, which may limit its long-term value. While it scores a moderate 6/10, it's a handy piece for those prioritizing capacity and cost over durability.

The Platinum Elite Check-In Spinner, achieving a 7/10 score, is noted for its durable high-density nylon fabric reinforced with DuraGuard® coating. While we appreciated the expandable design adding versatility, its 11.5 lbs weight might not suit all travelers. The telescopic handle occasionally lacks smoothness, but the suitcase earns points for its sturdy construction. It's a recommended option if durability and resilience to stains and abrasions are crucial for your travels.

With an 8/10 rating, The Medium in Cloud Gray impresses with its robust polycarbonate shell that's ready for the roughest handling. During our review, we appreciated its TSA-compliant lock and smooth 360° wheels, although its susceptibility to scuffs and limited handle adjustments stood out as minor drawbacks. Despite these, it's an excellent choice for a reliable travel companion, especially if durability is high on your priority list.

The Check-In Roller, scoring 7/10, is a standout for travelers in need of significant storage and a useful built-in weight indicator to prevent surprise fees. In our testing, the suitcase's polycarbonate shell scratched too easily, tarnishing its appearance. Still, it offers expansive room and handy features like cushioned handles, making it a highly functional option despite some aesthetic drawbacks.

For those who prioritize security and durability, the Framelock Max Spinner by Samsonite offers a robust and stylish choice. This suitcase features a durable polycarbonate shell and the peace of mind of the Eazylock™ mechanism, a TSA-approved locking system. Its 360° dual spinner wheels make navigating airport crowds a breeze. With an 8/10 rating, it stands out for its superior build quality, though it might not fit everyone's budget or color preference and could feel too large for some travelers.