25 Best Mascaras for Every Lash Look in 2025

25 Best Mascaras for Every Lash Look in 2025

July 18, 2025

Overview

Discover the ultimate mascara collection for 2025 and beyond, designed to elevate every lash look imaginable. This guide curates 25 of the best mascaras on the market, expertly chosen to cater to a diverse range of needs, from volumizing and lengthening to defining and waterproof formulas. Explore expert recommendations, application tips, and reviews to find your perfect mascara match, whether you're aiming for a natural daytime look or a dramatic evening statement. This guide promises to help you achieve your desired eye makeup looks all year round.

Magdalena Fazekas

In this guide

Best Mascaras for Voluminous LashesLengthening Mascaras for a Dramatic EffectWaterproof Mascaras for All-Day Wear

Our picks

The Best Mascara for Voluminous Lashes: Better Than Sex Mascara, $29.00

The Best Lengthening Mascara for Dramatic Eyes: LE VOLUME DE CHANEL, $40.00

The Best Defining Mascara for Natural Looks: Lash Power Mascara, $27.00

The Most Reliable Waterproof Mascara: Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara, $16.00

The Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes: La Roche-Posay Toleriane Waterproof Mascara, $26.00

The Best Drugstore Mascara Find: L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Panorama Mascara, $12.39

The Best Mascara for Everyday Wear: Lash Slick, $20.00

Best Mascaras for Voluminous Lashes

Enhance your lashes with these top-rated mascaras for maximum volume and impact.

7.5

Listful
Score

LE VOLUME DE CHANEL

$40.00

LE VOLUME DE CHANEL offers undeniable volume and length, perfect for those looking to make a bold statement. Our tests reveal a wet formula that may affect long-term curl and can cause occasional clumping. However, its performance in adding substantial volume and definition makes it a high-end choice, elevating any makeup look with luxury precision.

Chanel logo

$40.00

at Chanel

The Good

Provides significant volume and length to lashes.

The Bad

The wet formula may cause lashes to lose curl.

Some users experience clumping with the wet formula.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false


6.5

Listful
Score

Lancôme Monsieur Big Mascara

$16.00

Monsieur Big Mascara by Lancôme offers considerable volume for a dramatic, fuller lash appearance. Despite some application challenges due to the large brush and possible clumping if over-applied, its long-lasting wear without smudging makes it attractive for those seeking intense volume. However, note the removal process demands effort, which could affect daily convenience.

The Good

Provides intense volume, making lashes appear fuller and more dramatic.

Long-lasting wear without smudging or flaking throughout the day.

The Bad

The large brush size can make precise application challenging, especially on lower lashes.

The thick formula may lead to clumping if too many layers are applied.

Some users find the mascara difficult to remove, requiring more effort during cleansing.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false


6

Listful
Score

KUSH High Volumizing Mascara

$19.60

KUSH High Volumizing Mascara by Milk Makeup impressed us with its unique conditioning capabilities via hemp-derived cannabis seed oil. However, flaking and smudging during wear may compromise its reliability. While some users experience heaviness, the vegan and cruelty-free formula is appealing for volume seekers, though its challenging removal may be a consideration.

The Good

Provides significant volume and length to lashes.

Contains hemp-derived cannabis seed oil for conditioning lashes.

Vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free formula.

The Bad

Some users report smudging and flaking during wear.

Formula may feel heavy and clumpy upon application.

Difficult to remove compared to other mascaras.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false


6

Listful
Score

Dark Star Mascara

$34.00

Dark Star Mascara beckons those seeking bold, voluminous lash impact, with its intricate brush and dramatic finish. Despite its modest 6/10 rating due to clumping and flaking issues, its defining qualities are hard to ignore. Our experience shows its gel-hybrid formula delivers a bold, full-lash effect, although care is advised for those with smaller eyes when handling the large brush.

The Good

Provides significant volume and definition to lashes.

The Bad

Some users report clumping and flaking during wear.

The large brush size may make application challenging for some.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false


6.5

Listful
Score

Fullest Volumizing Mascara

$29.00

Fullest Volumizing Mascara is your go-to for luxurious volume, making lashes appear denser and more pronounced despite its 6.5/10 score. It provides a compelling volumizing pay-off, yet some users note flaking and a challenging large brush. If you marvel at impactful lashes, this might be your daily indulgence, though its drawbacks need a forgiving approach.

The Good

Provides significant volume, making lashes appear fuller and thicker.

The Bad

Some users report flaking during wear.

The large brush size may be challenging for those with smaller eyes.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: false / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: true


8.5

Listful
Score

Better Than Sex Mascara

$29.00

Better Than Sex Mascara impresses with its towering 8.5/10 score, deservedly earning a MVP spot in the volumizing field. Superior length and volume transform any lash backdrop into a head-turning spectacle. Nonetheless, its tendency to flake or smudge during prolonged wear is noteworthy, particularly if topping the day-long performance chart is a priority. Overall, it’s a must-have for those seeking a dramatic flutter.

The Good

Provides significant volume and length to lashes.

The Bad

Flakes onto the under-eye area within hours of application.

Requires an eyelash curler for optimal curl effect.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false


7.5

Listful
Score

LASH CLASH EXTREME VOLUME MASCARA

$33.00

LASH CLASH EXTREME VOLUME MASCARA elevates your lashes with striking drama and fullness, capturing a notable 7.5/10 score. Our review highlights its ability to deliver instant volume and impressive curl with just one coat. While some users experienced difficulties with removal and inconsistent volumizing effects, this mascara leaves a lasting impression with its bold, definitional prowess. Perfect for nights out when your eyes are the main attraction, just ensure you have a good makeup remover at hand.

The Good

Provides instant drama and volume with just one coat.

Holds a curl effectively without clumping.

The Bad

Some users find it lacks volumizing effect.

Difficult to remove, requiring multiple cleansers.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: true


8.5

Listful
Score

BADgal BANG! Mascara by Benefit Cosmetics

$27.00

Benefit Cosmetics’ BADgal BANG! Mascara scores a commendable 8.5/10 for its volume-boosting prowess and lightweight feel, making lashes comfortable for all-day wear. The flexible brush design applies product precisely, ensuring each lash is defined without clumping. While minor smudging and potential transfer onto eyelids were noted, in our experience, this mascara is perfect for those looking to make a bold statement in both length and volume, albeit requiring periodic touch-ups throughout the day.

The Good

Provides significant volume without clumping.

Lightweight formula allows for comfortable, all-day wear.

Flexible brush design enables precise application.

The Bad

Some users report smudging after extended wear.

Wet formula may transfer onto eyelids during application.

Packaging can attract dirt and fingerprints easily.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: true


7

Listful
Score

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Panorama Mascara

$12.39

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Panorama Mascara is a wallet-friendly gem delivering rich black color, earning a robust 7/10 in our assessments despite some clumping concerns. It excels in providing enhanced lash visibility, ensuring lashes stand out dramatically. However, some users reported challenges in maintaining curl with this formula. Ideal for budget-conscious beauty lovers seeking bold, daily wear, this mascara offers substantial impact without breaking the bank, just be prepared for additional blending if clumps appear.

The Good

Provides a dark black color that enhances lash appearance.

The Bad

Some users report clumping during application.

May not hold curl effectively for all users.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false

Lengthening Mascaras for a Dramatic Effect

Discover mascaras designed to elongate lashes and create a stunning, eye-opening look.

7.5

Listful
Score

Lash Power Mascara

$27.00

Clinique's Lash Power Mascara thrives in environments with sweat, humidity, and tears, making it a powerhouse for long-lasting wear. During our review, the thin brush effectively defined and lengthened each lash, but its natural look and removal difficulty might not appeal to those seeking dramatic results. It's a solid option for all-day reliability with a natural finish.

The Good

Resists flaking and smudging, lasting through sweat, humidity, and tears.

The thin brush catches every lash and separates while lengthening.

The Bad

Some users find it difficult to remove, even with makeup remover.

The result isn't dramatic; it provides a more natural look.

Volumizing: false / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: true / Clump-Free: true


8.5

Listful
Score

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara

$9.99

Maybelline’s Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara is perfect for those prioritizing length and curl retention. During our testing, we found it creates an eye-catching effect with a flexible wand that delicately coats every lash. Despite occasional flaking, its lightweight formula is a strong choice for achieving lengthened lashes, without the heaviness, at an attractive price point.

The Good

The mascara effectively lengthens lashes, providing a noticeable increase in length.

The flexible wand allows for easy application, reaching even the smallest lashes.

The formula is lightweight and doesn't weigh down lashes, maintaining curl throughout the day.

The Bad

The mascara may flake after a few hours of wear, leading to potential smudging.

The flexible wand may be too delicate for some users, making control during application challenging.

The mascara doesn't provide as much volume as some other mascaras, focusing more on length.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: true


7.5

Listful
Score

Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara

$35.00

With the Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara, say goodbye to lackluster lashes. We found that its unique curved brush delivers striking volume and curl with just a swipe, providing an elegant, lifted look that lasts. However, while its intensity scores high at 7.5/10, multiple coats may lead to clumping and some struggle with removal. If you desire definition and dramatic effect without compromising longevity, this may be your luxurious go-to.

The Good

Provides significant volume, length, and curl with just one coat.

The curved brush effectively lifts and curls lashes.

Long-lasting formula with minimal flaking or smudging.

The Bad

Applying multiple coats may lead to clumping.

The large, curved brush can make lower lash application challenging.

Some users find the formula difficult to remove completely.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false


7

Listful
Score

Tarte tartelette Tubing Mascara

$15.00

The Tarte tartelette Tubing Mascara is your wallet-friendly option for impressive length. Our testing showed it excels in lengthening, aided by moisturizing shea butter and castor oil, but it might not satisfy volume seekers. Scoring a decent 7/10, its ease of removal and flake-free promise make it a practical daily pick for those avoiding waterproof challenges. Note, some users mention potential flaking, a caveat for all-day wear lovers.

The Good

Provides significant lengthening effect.

Easy removal with warm water.

Contains moisturizing ingredients like shea butter and castor oil.

The Bad

Some users report flaking after a few hours.

May not provide as much volume as other mascaras.

Not waterproof; may smudge in wet conditions.

Volumizing: false / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: true


8

Listful
Score

Roller Lash Mascara by Benefit Cosmetics

$26.00

During our review, Benefit Cosmetics' Roller Lash Mascara captivated us with its defining and curling prowess. Thanks to the Hook ‘n' Roll™ brush, each lash is meticulously lifted and separated, giving a natural yet polished flair. Although some reported minor smudging on oily eyelids, it remains a strong contender at 8/10 for its water-resistant capability, making it a reliable choice for everyday wearers looking for effortless elegance.

The Good

The Hook ‘n' Roll™ brush effectively catches, separates, and curls each lash.

The mascara is water-resistant, providing durability against tears and humidity.

The Bad

Some users report smudging and transfer, especially on oily skin or hooded eyelids.

The mascara may not add significant volume to lashes.

Volumizing: false / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: true


6

Listful
Score

Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara

$15.88

Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara transforms your lashes for a striking impact. Despite its 6/10 score, its natural volumizing and lengthening properties shine through, along with a waterproof formula for all-day comfort. While some may find it occasionally clumpy or smudgy in humid conditions, it remains a great choice for enthusiasts keen on nourishing their lashes while achieving standout looks.

The Good

Provides the appearance of naturally longer and thicker lashes, enhancing overall eye makeup look.

Promotes lash health and flexibility, ensuring that your lashes remain strong and healthy even with daily use of mascara.

Waterproof formula allows for all-day curl without smudging or flaking, giving you a fresh look throughout the day without needing touch-ups.

The Bad

May clump if too many coats are applied.

Some users reported that the mascara can smudge slightly in humid conditions.

The price point may be higher than some other mascaras on the market.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false


7

Listful
Score

Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara

$29.00

Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara captures the essence of lifted, voluminous finery with its unique wand design. Scoring a fair 7/10, it combines length and curl for mesmerising results, perfect for daily sophistication. Note, though, its clumping risk - practice makes perfect with this tool, eventually rewarding precision and patience with a lusciously enhanced appearance.

The Good

Effectively lifts and curls lashes, providing a noticeable enhancement.

The Bad

The unique wand design may require practice to achieve optimal results.

Some users experience clumping if too much product is applied.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: false


7

Listful
Score

ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara

$29.00

The ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara offers a dual-sided brush that we found effective in customizing both volume and length, maintaining a flake-resistant look all day long. While this mascara earned a 7/10 in our testing due to reports of quick drying and some eye irritation, its definition and curl-hold capabilities shine through. Ideal for those who prioritize flake-free application, but be mindful if you have sensitive eyes. A solid choice for those seeking drama without waterproof barriers.

The Good

The dual-sided brush allows for customizable application, enhancing both volume and length.

The formula is flake-resistant and holds a curl throughout the day.

The Bad

Some users report eye irritation after prolonged use.

The mascara dries quickly, making it difficult to apply multiple coats.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: true

Defining Mascaras for Natural-Looking Lashes

Find mascaras that separate and define lashes for a refined, everyday makeup look.

6.5

Listful
Score

Lash Slick

$20.00

For those favoring subtle elegance, Lash Slick stands out with a score of 6.5/10 in our trials. Its lightweight formula enhances natural beauty with a gentle, lengthening touch, ideal for minimalists. Note though, its curl retention over time and lack of waterproofing may concern those expecting enduring definition. Despite these caveats, it remains a commendable option for a fuss-free, everyday look with easy wash-off.

The Good

Provides a natural, lengthened look with a lightweight formula.

The Bad

Some users report that lashes lose curl after a few hours.

The mascara is not waterproof and may smudge if eyes become watery.

Volumizing: false / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: false / Clump-Free: true

Waterproof Mascaras for All-Day Wear

Explore mascaras that withstand water, sweat, and humidity, keeping your lashes perfect.

6.5

Listful
Score

Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara

$16.00

During our review, the Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara impressed us with its ability to maintain curl throughout the day. While the hourglass brush shape can make application tricky, this mascara excels in volumizing and lengthening. However, some users noted significant flaking and smudging as the day went on. Despite these drawbacks, it's worth considering for those seeking dramatic lash transformation.

The Good

Effectively holds curl throughout the day.

The Bad

Some users report significant flaking and smudging.

The brush's hourglass shape can make application challenging.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: true / Clump-Free: false


8

Listful
Score

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara

$8.32

Maybelline's Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara scored high in our testing, offering impressive length and volume without clumping. Infused with bamboo extract, it keeps lashes lightweight and flexible. Although the waterproof formula resists smudging and flaking, we found removal to be challenging. Overall, an excellent option for all-day wear at a competitive price, especially for those seeking substantial length and volume.

The Good

Provides impressive length and volume without clumping.

Waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear without smudging or flaking.

Infused with bamboo extract for lightweight, flexible lashes.

The Bad

Difficult to remove, even with makeup remover.

Some users report the brush feels flimsy during application.

May not provide the intense volume some users expect.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: true / Clump-Free: true


7

Listful
Score

High Impact Waterproof Mascara

$27.00

For everyday definition without the weight, Clinique's High Impact Waterproof Mascara is an appealing choice. Our experience shows it defines without flaking, although some clumping might occur during application. Mink straight lashes may notice a challenge in curl retention, making it best suited for naturally curved lashes. Despite these issues, the lightweight formula ensures comfort throughout the day.

The Good

Provides excellent definition and does not flake throughout the day.

The formula is lightweight and doesn't make lashes feel stiff.

The Bad

Some users report significant clumping during application.

May not hold a curl effectively, especially for straight lashes.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: true / Clump-Free: false


9

Listful
Score

Définicils Waterproof Mascara

$34.00

In our evaluations, Définicils Waterproof Mascara emerged as a top contender, thanks to its superior definition and long-lasting wear. Its clump-free formula effectively separates and lengthens lashes, making it an ideal choice for a clean, defined look. Some users experienced quick drying but found the overall performance and longevity excellent for waterproof needs, despite its less volumizing effect.

The Good

Effectively separates lashes for a defined look.

Provides long-lasting waterproof wear without smudging.

Lengthens lashes without clumping.

The Bad

Some users report the mascara dries out quickly.

Difficult to remove without an oil-based cleanser.

Does not add significant volume to lashes.

Volumizing: false / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: true / Clump-Free: true


7

Listful
Score

M·A·CStack Waterproof Mascara

$20.30

Our tests revealed M·A·CStack Waterproof Mascara's buildable formula excels in providing customizable volume and definition. Though its wetness can cause initial clumping, we found it ideal for contact lens wearers with ophthalmologist-tested assurance. Despite removal difficulties, it stands strong under humidity and tears, making it a dependable partner for all-day lash perfection.

The Good

Provides buildable volume and length without clumping.

Long-lasting waterproof formula that stays put all day.

Suitable for contact lens wearers and ophthalmologist tested.

The Bad

Some users report the formula is too wet, leading to clumping.

May cause lashes to lose curl over time.

Some users find it difficult to remove.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: true / Clump-Free: true


8

Listful
Score

Lancôme Lash Idôle Waterproof Mascara

$21.00

Lancôme Lash Idôle Waterproof Mascara stands strong with an 8/10 rating thanks to its excellent separation and long-lasting wear. We loved the curved silicone brush's precision, though some users find removal challenging. It's ideal for those with sensitive eyes, offering a smudge-proof finish that lasts all day and night. While the cost might be a consideration, this mascara is your ally for occasions where reliable endurance and definition are non-negotiable, ensuring your eyes stay alluringly highlighted.

The Good

The curved silicone brush effectively separates lashes and reaches hard-to-reach angles.

The waterproof formula provides long-lasting wear without flaking or smudging.

The mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

The Bad

Some users find the mascara difficult to remove, requiring patience and proper makeup remover.

The product is relatively expensive compared to other mascaras.

Some users report that the mascara can become clumpy if too much product is applied.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: true / Waterproof: true / Clump-Free: false

Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

Gentle formulas designed for sensitive eyes. Achieve a perfect lash look without irritation.

7.5

Listful
Score

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Waterproof Mascara

$26.00

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Waterproof Mascara, scoring 7.5/10, stands out for those with sensitive eyes craving comfort and volume. Though its smudging under wet exposure could deter some enthusiasts, it remains a reliable choice for natural-looking lashes, made with love for sensitive eyes. Its clump-free promise ensures a care-free application, ideal for those valuing simplicity and gentle care.

The Good

Provides natural-looking volume and definition without clumping.

Suitable for sensitive eyes and daily use.

The Bad

Some users report smudging by the end of the day.

May not provide significant lengthening effect.

Volumizing: true / Lengthening: false / Waterproof: true / Clump-Free: true

Share

More Guides

Latest Articles