Father's Day Gift Guide 2025: The Best Toasters for Dad
July 23, 2025
Overview
This Father's Day, upgrade Dad's breakfast game with our ultimate toaster guide! We've curated a comprehensive selection of the best toasters on the market, perfect for every preference and budget. Whether Dad enjoys perfectly toasted bagels, crispy bread, or specialized functions, you'll find the ideal appliance to elevate his morning routine. From sleek, modern designs to classic, reliable models, explore our expert recommendations and discover the perfect toaster to show Dad you care. Get ready to celebrate Father's Day 2025 with the gift of perfectly toasted goodness!
Our picks
The Most Advanced Toaster with Bagel Settings: R180 Connect Smart Toaster, $349.95
The Best Budget-Friendly Toaster: Quality on a Dime: 2 Slice Toaster, $39.99
Best 2-Slice Toasters for Dad
Compact and efficient toasters perfect for single servings or smaller households.
6
Listful
Score
Cuisinart 2-Slice Toaster
$71.95
In our review, the Cuisinart 2-Slice Toaster stood out for its ability to handle oversized bread slices and thick bagels, thanks to its accommodating slots. While the handy memory save feature and easy-to-read controls are a plus, it's important to note that during testing, the top between the slices got excessively hot. Its inconsistent performance tints its overall appeal, earning a middle-ground score of 6/10.
The Good
• Accommodates oversized slices of bread and thick bagels.
• Very easy to read controls.
• Handy memory save feature.
The Bad
• Top of the toaster between the slices gets excessively hot.
• Poor bagel toasting performance.
• Inconsistent toasting performance.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
7
Listful
Score
2 Slice Toaster
$149.99
KitchenAid’s 2 Slice Toaster, earning a 7/10 score, blends versatility and sleek design. Its multiple functions, from 'A Little Longer' to defrost, cater to diverse breakfast preferences, while extra-wide slots accommodate thicker breads. However, in our experience, the light toasting on high settings and slower operation could be a drawback for those wanting quick, dark toast, making this an ideal choice for more leisurely toast lovers.
The Good
• Extra-wide slots accommodate various bread types, including bagels and thick slices.
• Multiple toasting functions like Bagel, Defrost, Reheat, and 'A Little Longer' enhance versatility.
• Sleek design available in multiple colors adds aesthetic appeal to the kitchen.
The Bad
• Even on the highest setting, toasting may be too light for some preferences.
• The toaster operates slower compared to some competitors.
• The lever's lift function could be improved for easier retrieval of smaller items.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
7
Listful
Score
Black+Decker Stainless Steel Toaster
$47.84
For a budget-conscious dad wanting style, the Black+Decker Stainless Steel Toaster, priced at just $47.84, pairs an attractive finish with practical features like extra-wide slots. However, our review found it can struggle with consistent toasting over time, earning a score of 7/10. It serves well for simple toasting tasks, despite occasional challenges with durability.
The Good
• Extra-wide slots accommodate thick breads and bagels.
• Durable stainless steel finish enhances kitchen aesthetics.
The Bad
• Some users report uneven toasting over time.
• Certain components may break after extended use.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
6.5
Listful
Score
Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster
$23.10
With practical features and a low price, the Amazon Basics 2 Slice Toaster makes a reliable option with its extra-wide slots and removable crumb tray for easy cleaning. During our review, it showed occasionally uneven results and a hot exterior, earning a 6.5/10 score. It remains a solid choice for simple toasting tasks where sophistication is second to budget.
The Good
• Extra-wide slots accommodate thick slices and bagels.
• Bagel setting toasts the cut side while keeping the outer part soft.
• Removable crumb tray allows for easy cleaning.
The Bad
• Toaster can sometimes leave uneven browning, especially when both slots are in use.
• Exterior gets hot during use, posing a burn risk.
• Frozen setting doesn't add value; frozen waffles come out better on the regular toast setting.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
7
Listful
Score
ZWILLING Enfinigy 2-Slot Toaster
$99.99
The ZWILLING Enfinigy 2-Slot Toaster combines sleek design with effective toasting capabilities but falls short with some uneven results, ranked at 7/10 in our trials. Its thermal-safety concern requires caution, making it a stylish, yet cautiously practical option suitable for a dad who enjoys modern elegance in his kitchen without compromise on space.
The Good
• Sleek and modern design enhances kitchen aesthetics.
• Even at its highest setting, your toast won’t go beyond dark brown.
The Bad
• The toaster's exterior can become very hot during use.
• Some users report uneven toasting, with one side darker than the other.
• The toaster lacks a single-slot mode, heating both slots even when toasting one slice.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
7.5
Listful
Score
Breville Toast Select Luxe Toaster
$199.95
For the dad with a taste for luxury and style, the Breville Toast Select Luxe Toaster offers sleek design and intuitive controls. Its features, including a bagel setting and toast boost, ensure optimal toasting results. During our review, the high-end aesthetics and consistent performance earned it a 7.5/10, although its two-slot design and higher price point are worth considering. This model stands out as a sophisticated choice for Dads who value premium design and control.
The Good
• Sleek design with intuitive controls.
The Bad
• High price point compared to other toasters.
• Limited toasting capacity with only two slots.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
Family-Sized 4-Slice Toasters
Toasters that can handle breakfast for the whole family with ease and speed.
5.5
Listful
Score
GE 4 Slice Toaster
$39.99
The GE 4 Slice Toaster is budget-friendly at $39.99, with wide slots that cater to various bread sizes. However, it's worth noting that some users reported uneven toasting, influencing its score of 5.5/10. Despite its appealingly low price, our experience suggests it may not provide the most reliable long-term performance, making it perfect for those who prioritize cost over perfection.
The Good
• Features wide slots accommodating various bread sizes.
The Bad
• Some users report uneven toasting results.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
9
Listful
Score
Breville Smart Toaster
$199.95
The Breville Smart Toaster, priced at $199.95, tops our list with a 9/10 score for its consistently even toasting and sleek stainless steel design. Its wide slots accommodate various bread types, although it takes slightly longer to toast. During testing, we found it offered an exceptional blend of style and performance, making it the ultimate premium gift for Dad’s breakfast table.
The Good
• Consistent and even toasting results.
• Sleek and modern brushed stainless steel design.
• Wide slots fit various bread types and sizes.
The Bad
• Can be pricey compared to other toasters.
• Some users reported that it takes longer to toast than cheaper models.
• Metal exterior can get quite hot during use.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
7.5
Listful
Score
Classic 4 Slice Toaster
$69.95
Earning a 7.5/10 score, the Classic 4 Slice Toaster provides both functionality and style for just $69.95. Its dual control panels offer personalized settings for each side, making it a practical fit for a busy family. Although some reports of inconsistent toasting exist, our experience suggests it manages well with varied breakfast needs, though cleaning might be easier if the crumb trays weren't rear-positioned.
The Good
• Dual control panels allow for different settings on each side.
• Stylish, compact design fits well in most kitchens.
• Features include bagel, defrost, and reheat settings.
The Bad
• Some users report inconsistent toasting results.
• Exterior can become hot during use.
• Crumb trays are located at the rear, making cleaning less convenient.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
6.5
Listful
Score
Oster 4-Slice Toaster
$112.12
The Oster 4-Slice Toaster catches the eye with its digital touchscreen and wide slot capacity, welcoming artisan breads and bagels alike. While it boasts multiple functions, our review showed that its consistent performance leaves something to be desired, resulting in a more moderate score of 6.5/10. It's best suited for those who prioritize features like the reheating function over flawless design.
The Good
• Digital touchscreen interface for easy operation.
• 6 shade settings to customize toast preferences.
• Functions for bagels, reheating, and frozen items.
The Bad
• Limited availability of replacement parts.
• Potential for uneven toasting results.
• Design may not fit all kitchen aesthetics.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
6
Listful
Score
Elite Gourmet 4-Slice Toaster
$45.99
Offering a budget-friendly option, the Elite Gourmet 4-Slice Toaster is ideal for lovers of thick bread and bagels with its ample slots. Our review highlights the handy warming rack feature, though the absence of a bagel setting and reports of uneven results stand out, earning a 6/10 score. Best for casual toasting needs, it makes a practical yet imperfect addition to any kitchen.
The Good
• Extra-wide slots accommodate thick slices of bread and bagels.
• Built-in warming rack for heating pastries and croissants.
• Defrost function allows easy toasting of frozen bread.
The Bad
• Lack of a dedicated bagel setting may result in uneven toasting.
• Some users report uneven toasting requiring multiple cycles.
• Short power cord limits placement options.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: false / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
6
Listful
Score
Oster 4-Slice Toaster
$69.99
Big enough for family breakfasts, the Oster 4-Slice Toaster incorporates features like a removable crumb tray and extra-wide slots for flexibility. However, our testing pointed to uneven toasting and durability concerns that limit its appeal, reflected in its 6/10 score. It’s a suitable choice for those who need extra capacity but can overlook some performance inconsistencies.
The Good
• Extra-wide slots accommodate various bread sizes, including bagels and artisan breads.
• Features a removable crumb tray for easy cleaning.
• Includes bagel and frozen settings for versatile toasting options.
The Bad
• Some users report uneven toasting, with one side darker than the other.
• Durability concerns, with reports of malfunctioning after a short period.
• Exterior can get hot during use, posing a burn risk.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
5.5
Listful
Score
4 Slice Toaster
$179.99
The KitchenAid 4 Slice Toaster brings high lift convenience and versatile settings, though its slower operation earned it a mid-tier 5.5/10 in our review. While accommodating for thicker bread types, its control layout might be awkward for some users. It’s a choice for those who appreciate function over frantic speed during breakfast preparation.
The Good
• Extra-wide slots accommodate various bread sizes, including bagels and thick slices.
• High lift lever allows easy retrieval of smaller items without burning fingers.
• Multiple functions like Bagel, Defrost, Reheat, and Little Longer enhance versatility.
The Bad
• Some users report uneven toasting, with one side darker than the other.
• The toaster operates slower compared to other models.
• Control placement may be awkward, with controls on the side and lever on the front.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
Toasters with Bagel Settings
Featuring settings designed for perfectly toasted bagels, every time.
7.5
Listful
Score
Breville Bit More Toaster
$87.99
The Breville Bit More Toaster is a tech-savvy dad's dream with its unique 'A Bit More' button for precise extra toasting time. While it tackles bagels and defrosting duties quite well, our testing revealed occasional inconsistent results and a rather hot exterior, which could be concerning. Scoring a mid-range 7.5/10, it’s great for those who value toasting control over safety concerns.
The Good
• The 'A Bit More' button allows for precise toasting adjustments.
The Bad
• Some users report inconsistent toasting performance over time.
• The toaster's exterior can become quite hot during use.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
Extra-Wide Slot Toasters for Dad
Accommodating thick-cut bread, artisanal loaves, and even waffles.
5.5
Listful
Score
2-Slice Toaster with Extra-Wide Slots
$16.99
For an affordable and compact solution, consider the 2-Slice Toaster with Extra-Wide Slots. Priced to please at just $16.99, it handles bagels and thick bread well, although our experience found it sometimes struggles with consistent toasting and cleaning complexity. With a score of 5.5/10, it’s a choice for small kitchens on a budget where stellar performance is not a top priority.
The Good
• Extra-wide slots accommodate thick slices of bread and bagels without squishing them.
• The toaster is lightweight and compact, making it suitable for small kitchens or limited counter space.
• The shade selector dial allows for customization of toast browning levels.
The Bad
• Some users report inconsistent toasting performance, especially at lower settings.
• The crumb tray does not detach, making cleaning more challenging.
• The top of the toaster between the slices gets excessively hot during use.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
6
Listful
Score
GE 4 Slice Toaster
$49.00
If Dad thrives on variety at breakfast, the GE 4 Slice Toaster is a budget-friendly option that's easy on the wallet. It features wide slots and 7 shade settings, catering effortlessly to different bread types and personal preferences. However, in our testing, this model exhibits some uneven toasting and heat issues, scoring a 6/10. While it's not our top-rated choice, it suits those prioritizing affordability over perfection and who can overlook occasional performance quirks.
The Good
• Features wide slots accommodating various bread sizes.
• Offers 7 shade settings for customized toasting.
• Includes a removable crumb tray for easy cleaning.
The Bad
• Some users report uneven toasting.
• Exterior can become hot during use.
• Some users noted a burning smell during operation.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
6.5
Listful
Score
Elite Gourmet 4 Slice Toaster
$51.99
The Elite Gourmet 4 Slice Toaster is a versatile and affordable option for families, offering wide slots and a useful warming rack. In our review, the digital countdown timer was a convenient feature, but uneven toasting and crumb tray design issues were evident. It earns a 6.5/10, balancing price and utility for those who can manage occasional repeat cycles for desired results, making it a practical choice for everyday use on a budget.
The Good
• Extra-wide slots accommodate various bread types, including artisan and thick slices.
• Built-in warming rack is useful for heating pastries and other items.
• Digital countdown timer provides clear visibility of remaining toasting time.
The Bad
• Some users report uneven toasting, requiring multiple cycles for desired results.
• Crumb tray design may lead to crumbs spilling during removal.
• Lack of a dedicated bagel setting results in inconsistent bagel toasting.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
Sleek, Modern Toasters for Father's Day
Stylish toasters that will look great on any kitchen countertop in 2025.
8.5
Listful
Score
R180 Connect Smart Toaster
$349.95
For the tech-savvy dad, the R180 Connect Smart Toaster impresses with its high-tech touchscreen interface and fast, even heating. While it boasts an 8.5/10 score, the lack of a crumb tray and learning curve for its many features could be a hurdle. Perfect for gadget enthusiasts, its sleek design and swift performance make it a standout choice for Father’s Day gifting, provided you have the counter space.
The Good
• The R180 Connect's touchscreen is incredibly easy to use, making it simple to customize your toasting settings and monitor your toaster's progress.
• The R180 Connect's improved heating system ensures even toasting and faster cooking times, making it perfect for busy mornings.
• The R180 Connect's sleek stainless steel design adds a modern touch to any kitchen countertop.
The Bad
• Some users have reported that the toaster takes up a bit more space on their countertop than they had anticipated.
• While the touchscreen interface is easy to use, some users have reported a slight learning curve when adjusting to the toaster's various features.
• Unfortunately, the R180 Connect does not come with a crumb tray, which can be a minor inconvenience for some users.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: false
8
Listful
Score
Smeg 4-slice Toaster
$237.00
Elevate Dad's kitchen with the Smeg 4-slice Toaster, a stylish retro addition that didn't fail to impress during our review. Its versatile functionalities earn it a solid 8/10 rating, though users should be mindful of occasional uneven toasting. Appreciated for its charming aesthetics and reliable functions such as auto eject, this toaster aligns with those favoring design over affordability.
The Good
• The toaster features a stylish retro design that enhances kitchen aesthetics.
• It offers multiple functions including defrost, reheat, and bagel settings for versatile toasting options.
The Bad
• Some users report uneven toasting and longer than expected cook times.
• The highest setting may not char white sandwich bread, requiring additional toasting cycles.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
5.5
Listful
Score
Digital 2-Slice Toaster
$149.99
Upgrade Dad's kitchen gadgets with the Digital 2-Slice Toaster, which stood out in our testing for its modern features like an LED display and additional toasting modes. This toaster offers six browning levels and a convenient 'add more time' option, though inconsistent performance and durability concerns were noted. Receiving a score of 5.5/10, it's ideal for those who prioritize style and digital precision in a space-saving design despite its limitations with bagel fit and heat management.
The Good
• Features 6 browning levels and 3 additional modes (bagel, reheat, and defrost), plus an add more time option.
• An intuitive LED digital display shows the remaining time.
• Includes a removable, dishwasher-safe crumb collector tray for easy cleaning.
The Bad
• Some users report issues with durability and inconsistent performance.
• The toaster can get very hot on top during use.
• Bagels fit tightly and are hard to retrieve.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
The Best Budget-Friendly Toaster
An affordable toaster that doesn't compromise on toasting quality or features.
5
Listful
Score
Cuisinart 2-Slice Toaster
$29.95
Compact yet affordable, the Cuisinart 2-Slice Toaster fits neatly into smaller kitchens. With a score of 5/10, this toaster's lack of an auto-eject feature and necessity for manual removal might be drawbacks. Nonetheless, its handy toast boost function and ability to defrost can make it a versatile, space-conscious option for those dreaming of including toasted bagels in their breakfast repertoire without splurging.
The Good
• The toaster features a compact design, making it suitable for kitchens with limited counter space.
The Bad
• The toaster lacks an auto-eject feature, requiring manual removal of toasted items.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: true / Defrost Function: true
5.5
Listful
Score
2 Slice Toaster
$39.99
Perfectly affordable at $39.99, this versatile 2 Slice Toaster features extra-wide slots ideal for bagels. However, during our review, we noted its short toast slots and power cord as limitations, reflected in its 5.5/10 score. Despite potential durability concerns, it's a practical choice for occasional use or as a secondary toaster for those who appreciate a budget-conscious purchase.
The Good
• The toaster features extra-wide slots to accommodate various bread sizes.
• The toaster includes a bagel setting for toasting bagels.
• The toaster has a defrost function for frozen bread.
The Bad
• The toaster's cord is very short, limiting placement options.
• The toast slots are too short for mid-sized slices of bread.
• The toaster may stop working shortly after purchase.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
High-End Luxury Toasters for Dad
Premium toasters with advanced features and superior performance.
8
Listful
Score
Smeg 4-Slice Toaster
$229.95
With its stylish retro design, the Smeg 4-Slice Toaster adds a touch of elegance to any kitchen, and our tests found its multiple functions including defrost really versatile. However, at a price of $229.95, it's a premium choice that's not without flaws; some users reported uneven toasting and insufficient heat at the highest setting. Thus, while it holds an 8/10 score, its value might depend on your preference for aesthetics and features.
The Good
• The toaster features a stylish retro design that enhances kitchen aesthetics.
• It offers multiple functions including defrost, reheat, and bagel settings for versatile toasting.
• The toaster has wide slots accommodating various bread sizes and thicknesses.
The Bad
• Some users report uneven toasting, especially with certain bread types.
• The highest setting may not sufficiently toast very thick or frozen items.
• The toaster is relatively expensive compared to other models.
Slot Count: 4-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
Toasters with Unique Features for Dad
Toasters with specialized functions such as defrost settings or digital displays.
6.5
Listful
Score
Clear View Toaster
$49.99
The Clear View Toaster, with its unique viewing window, ensures Dad can watch his toast's progress in real-time. This stylish, retro-inspired appliance excels in speed during our tests, delivering mid-level toast in just two minutes. However, its inconsistent toasting results and hot exterior, which earned it a 6.5/10 score, mean it might be better for smaller kitchens or those looking for a conversation-starting appliance.
The Good
• The toaster features a clear-view window, allowing users to monitor the toasting process.
• It offers quick toasting times, achieving a midlevel toast in just two minutes.
• The design is stylish and attractive, adding a retro touch to the kitchen.
The Bad
• The toaster has a large footprint, making it less suitable for smaller kitchens.
• Toasting consistency is inconsistent, with some slices coming out unevenly toasted.
• The glass front can become very hot during operation, posing a potential safety concern.
Slot Count: 2-Slice / Bagel Setting: true / Toast Boost: false / Defrost Function: true
Discover More Guides
Topics
Create Your Custom
AI Shopping Guide
Get personalized product recommendations tailored to your specific needs and preferences with our intelligent AI guide creator.
AI-Powered Recommendations
Instant Results
Free to use • No account required
Share
More Guides
Latest Articles