
Non-Toxic Baby Toys: Our Experts' Top Picks for 2025
July 21, 2025
Overview
Ensure your little one's playtime is safe and stimulating with our expert-curated list of non-toxic baby toys. We've researched the market to bring you the top picks for 2025, focusing on quality, safety, and developmental benefits. From sustainably sourced materials to engaging designs, discover toys that encourage exploration and learning without compromising your baby's health. Explore our selection of safe and fun options, all rigorously tested and selected for their non-toxic properties, so you can feel confident in every playtime experience for your baby.
Our picks
The Best Teether for Soothing Sore Gums: Sophie La Girafe Teether, $26.00
The Most Engaging Activity Mat for Tummy Time: Aila+Aiden 6-in-1 Play Mat & Play Gym, $54.99
The Best Building Blocks for Creative Play: Melissa & Doug Wooden Building Blocks, $17.95
The Most Sensory Toy for Visual Stimulation: FIVOENDAR Sensory Balls for Kids, $14.90
The Safest Rattles for Early Sensory Exploration: Rattle Buddy Sienna the Deer, $24.00
The Best Gift Set of Non-Toxic Toys: AJsupojouet High Contrast Baby Toys, $14.99
Soft & Safe: Plush Toys for Snuggles
Cuddly, non-toxic plush animals made from safe materials for baby's comfort and playtime.
Furnis Panda Bear Washcloth
$15.99
The Furnis Panda Bear Washcloth adds a fun twist to bath time with its charming hand-puppet design. Crafted from 100% certified organic cotton, it offers a gentle, safe choice for tender skin. While adult-sized, this washcloth brings interactive play to life, sparking creativity and delighting children during every wash. This eco-friendly product merges sensory development with social interaction, making it an adorable addition to your baby care routine.
The Good
• Made from 100% certified organic cotton, ensuring a soft and safe experience for babies.
• Designed as a hand puppet, making bath time more engaging and fun for children.
The Bad
• Sized for an adult hand, which may be too large for children to use comfortably.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: Sensory Development,Social Interaction,Creativity / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: true
PEIPEIWU Organic Cotton Lovey Blanket
$11.99
Embrace tactile exploration with the PEIPEIWU Organic Cotton Lovey Blanket. This adorable bunny-themed blanket, made from 100% organic cotton muslin, offers unmatched softness. While some find the built-in rattle slightly oversized, its sensory features, including crinkly ears, make it a comforting and engaging companion. Machine washable and breathable, it's a practical, eco-friendly choice that nurture's your baby's senses and promotes self-soothing, perfect for both playtime and sleep.
The Good
• Made from 100% organic cotton muslin, ensuring softness and breathability.
• Features a built-in rattle and crinkly ears to engage baby's senses.
• Machine washable and retains softness after multiple washes.
The Bad
• Some users found the head size larger than expected.
• The built-in rattle may not be suitable for all babies.
• Limited color options available.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: true
Rattle Buddy Sienna the Deer
$24.00
In our review, Rattle Buddy Sienna the Deer stands out as a delightful hand-knit treasure, crafted from 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton. Its eco-friendly design ensures peace of mind, while the phthalate-free rattle provides safe and engaging auditory stimulation. Although it lacks extensive customer reviews, its organic material and developmental benefits for motor and sensory skills make it a charming addition to any toy collection.
The Good
• Hand-knit using G.O.T.S. certified 100% organic cotton, ensuring a non-toxic and eco-friendly product.
• Features a phthalate-free rattle inside, providing safe auditory stimulation for infants.
The Bad
• Limited availability of customer reviews makes it difficult to assess user satisfaction.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: true
Cream Sherpa Bear
$40.00
The Cream Sherpa Bear offers an adorable, eco-conscious cuddling companion, crafted from GOTS-certified organic cotton and herbal dyes. Our experience suggests its hypoallergenic filling provides comfort, while ethical sourcing adds to its appeal. However, some concerns about product quality and customer service have been noted, making it essential to consider purchase circumstances carefully despite its snuggly charm.
The Good
• Made from 100% GOTS Certified organic cotton and dyed with herbal dyes containing antibacterial elements.
• Hand-stuffed with organic PLA fiber filling, which is naturally hypoallergenic and non-toxic.
• Ethically sourced from India, ensuring fair labor practices.
The Bad
• Some customers reported receiving defective products and poor customer service.
• Issues with shipping delays and lack of communication from the company.
• Concerns about product quality, including shedding material and loose threads.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: / Safety Certifications: GOTS / Eco-Friendly: true
Ernie the Elephant Plush Toy
$39.00
Let Ernie the Elephant Plush Toy be your little one's new best friend, offering comfort with its incredibly soft, 100% organic cotton sherpa. We found its compliance with multiple safety certifications provides peace of mind, though some might find the price a bit steep. In our testing, Ernie excelled in providing sensory development through touch, making it a cozy and secure choice for snuggles and play. This plush companion's organic materials highlight its commitment to sustainable practices.
The Good
• Made from 100% organic cotton sherpa, ensuring a soft and safe experience for babies.
• Complies with US ASTM F963, European EN71, and Canadian Consumer Product Safety Act standards, ensuring high safety standards.
The Bad
• Priced at $39.00, which may be considered high compared to other plush toys.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: ASTM,EN71 / Eco-Friendly: true
Scraptopus by Under the Nile
$21.78
Meet Scraptopus by Under the Nile, an endearing plush toy crafted from GOTS-certified organic Egyptian cotton. Our experience found it excels in sensory and motor skill development, with its safe, non-toxic materials providing comfort to tiny hands. While some customers had issues with the product descriptions and refund policies, Scraptopus’s washable nature adds practicality to its delightful design. This eco-friendly octopus perfectly combines safety, playfulness, and sustainability for your little one's playtime.
The Good
• Made from 100% organic Egyptian cotton, ensuring a safe and non-toxic experience for babies.
The Bad
• Some customers have reported dissatisfaction with product descriptions and refund policies.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: GOTS,CPSIA / Eco-Friendly: true
Teethers & Rattles: Soothing & Safe Play
Explore non-toxic teethers and rattles to soothe sore gums and stimulate sensory development.
OSTTRPO Baby Teether Toys
$13.99
Our experience shows that the OSTTRPO Baby Teether Toys excel in providing a natural, non-toxic choice for teething infants. Made from smooth wood, these teethers offer excellent sensory exploration and are perfectly sized for little hands. However, some parents might be cautious due to the lack of specific safety certifications. If you're seeking an eco-friendly option that encourages both sensory development and motor skills, these teethers are an engaging choice for curious infants.
The Good
• Crafted from natural wood, providing a non-toxic and eco-friendly option for teething babies.
• Designed in baby-friendly sizes, making them easy for tiny hands to grasp and explore.
The Bad
• Lack of specific safety certifications may raise concerns for some parents.
• Wooden material may not be as easy to sanitize as silicone or plastic alternatives.
Material: Wood / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: true
Koala Teether
$9.99
With its ergonomic design, the Koala Teether is both a practical and charming tool for soothing sore gums. Made from 100% food-grade silicone, it’s safe for babies while promoting motor skills with its easy-to-grasp shape. Our experience noted that it might be small for older infants, but its durability makes it a reliable choice for younger ones. Dishwasher safe and available in various colors, this teether combines style and functionality for everyday use.
The Good
• Made from 100% non-toxic, food-grade silicone, ensuring safety for babies.
• Designed to be easy to grasp by tiny fingers, promoting fine motor skills.
The Bad
• Some users found the teether to be too small for older babies with several teeth.
Material: Silicone / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: CE,CPC,FDA / Eco-Friendly: true
Sophie La Girafe Teether
$26.00
Sophie La Girafe Teether, made from 100% natural rubber, remains a beloved teething choice for over five decades. Our findings emphasize its easy-to-grasp shape and squeaker, promoting sensory development. While concerns about potential mold and price exist, the durable material and engaging design keep it a classic, trusted option for soothing sore gums and encouraging motor skills in infants.
The Good
• Made from 100% natural rubber, providing a safe and non-toxic teething option.
• Easy for small hands to grasp, promoting independent play and motor skill development.
• Features a squeaker that engages babies and stimulates auditory senses.
The Bad
• The squeaker hole can trap water, leading to potential mold growth if not cleaned properly.
• Some users report the paint wearing off after cleaning, raising concerns about durability.
• Priced higher than other teethers, which may not justify its value for some parents.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: CE / Eco-Friendly: true
Natursutten Starfish Teether
$15.99
The Natursutten Starfish Teether is a soothing beacon for teething babies, crafted from pure, natural rubber for a safe experience. Our experience highlights its soft texture and starfish design as perfect for tiny fingers, promoting both relief and sensory development. Despite some durability concerns, its eco-friendly credentials and easy-care requirements make it an appealing alternative to plastic teethers.
The Good
• Made from 100% natural rubber, free from BPA, phthalates, and other harmful chemicals.
• Soft texture provides comfort for teething babies.
• Starfish design is easy for small hands to grasp.
The Bad
• Some users report the teether attracts lint and dust.
• Concerns about durability, with reports of the product coming apart at the seams.
• Not dishwasher safe; requires hand washing with mild soap and warm water.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: ASTM,EN71,CE / Eco-Friendly: true
Teething Ears Dinos
$22.00
Introduce your baby to the Teething Ears Dinos, a safe and eco-friendly teether made from untreated Indian hardwood and organic cotton. Our experience shows that the combination of materials offers soothing relief, though some parents noted the wood can be hard for chewing. Despite this, the soft cotton ears provide a gentle, sensory experience that's perfect for motor skill development. This teether stands out for its organic construction, ensuring your child's playtime is both fun and safe.
The Good
• Made from untreated Indian hardwood and organic cotton, ensuring safety and eco-friendliness.
The Bad
• The wooden component may be hard for some babies to chew on comfortably.
Material: Wood,Organic / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: true
Activity Mats: Safe Spaces for Exploration
Interactive and stimulating activity mats to encourage tummy time and early learning.
The Play Gym
$140.00
The Play Gym is a standout choice for parents desiring a multi-functional activity center that grows with their child. Made with non-toxic, FSC-certified materials, it provides stage-based developmental activities from newborn through toddlerhood. Although its premium price is higher than other options, our review found its durability, safety, and engaging features to be well worth the investment. This eco-friendly play gym not only encourages motor and cognitive skills but also offers peace of mind for safety-conscious parents.
The Good
• Made from non-toxic materials, including FSC Certified sustainable beech wood and Lyocell fabric.
• Designed to grow with the child, offering stage-based developmental activities from newborn to toddler.
The Bad
• The price point is higher compared to other play gyms, which may be a consideration for some buyers.
Material: Wood,Organic,Silicone / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Cognitive Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: CPSC / Eco-Friendly: true
Aila+Aiden 6-in-1 Play Mat & Play Gym
$54.99
The Aila+Aiden 6-in-1 Play Mat & Play Gym offers a dynamic play environment that adapts to your child's needs. In our review, its versatility in transforming from a tummy time mat to a ball pit makes it a multifunctional powerhouse, although setting up the mesh sides can be challenging. This secure, spacious mat fosters motor, cognitive, and sensory development, making it an all-round winner for growing families.
The Good
• The play gym offers six different uses, including tummy time mat, baby gym, pop-up mesh fence, high contrast book, ball pit, and storage bag.
• The play mat is generously padded and features a non-slip base, providing a secure and comfortable environment for babies.
The Bad
• Some users have noted that the mesh sides can be tricky to pop up initially.
• The mat primarily requires spot cleaning due to its design, which may be inconvenient for some parents.
• Some users have noted the hanging toys could be slightly better attached.
Material: Plastic / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Cognitive Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: CPSC / Eco-Friendly: false
Organic Hemp Play Mat
$150.00
Create a nurturing play space with the Organic Hemp Play Mat, offering non-toxic comfort from organic hemp and linen. Our review found its eco-friendly composition and durability ideal for tummy time, though the initial odor and thinner-than-expected thickness are worth noting. While it falls at a higher price point, its customizable design and plush surface provide unparalleled peace of mind, supporting natural exploration.
The Good
• Made from organic hemp fiber and non-dyed linen fabric, ensuring a non-toxic and eco-friendly play environment.
• Customizable in size and thickness to suit individual needs and preferences.
• Handmade craftsmanship results in high-quality and durable construction.
The Bad
• Thickness may not meet all expectations, as some users found it thinner than anticipated.
• Initial odor upon arrival, likely due to shipping, which may require washing to eliminate.
• Higher price point compared to some other play mats on the market.
Material: Organic / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: true
Building Blocks: Fostering Creativity
Non-toxic building blocks to help babies develop motor skills and spark imaginative play.
Green Toys Block Set
$24.99
In our review, the Green Toys Block Set impressed with its eco-friendly design, made from 100% recycled plastic. While the blocks are lightweight and simple for toddlers to grasp, we noted that their assembly can be challenging due to loose connections. However, this set remains a top choice for promoting motor skills and creativity, enhanced by the easy cleaning process thanks to them being dishwasher safe. Perfect for environmentally conscious parents seeking non-toxic play options.
The Good
• Made from 100% recycled plastic, promoting environmental sustainability.
• Blocks are lightweight and easy for toddlers to handle.
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
The Bad
• Some blocks do not connect securely, leading to structures falling apart easily.
• Blocks are very light and don't fit together well, making them tricky and difficult to assemble.
• Some blocks don't mix well with each other, making this set quite difficult for young children to assemble.
Material: Plastic / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Cognitive Skills,Creativity / Safety Certifications: ASTM,CPSC,EN71,ISO / Eco-Friendly: true
ABC Wooden Block Cart by Melissa & Doug
$15.99
The ABC Wooden Block Cart by Melissa & Doug offers a charming classic toy experience, ideal for small hands. During our testing, we found the blocks size perfect for boosting motor skills and alphabet familiarization. However, some concerns about paint chipping and minor wood cracking were noted, which can compromise longevity. Despite these concerns, this block set is still a charming choice for early learning and exploration, ideal for fostering your child's early educational journey.
The Good
• The blocks are the correct size for infant and one-year-old hands.
The Bad
• The paint is chipping and peeling, stamped not engraved, wood is splintering and cracking.
• The blocks are very tiny and each block has two different letters which makes it difficult to arrange and to teach your child the Abc's.
Material: Wood / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Cognitive Skills / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: false
Simply Silicone Bamboo Sorter by Mary Meyer
$59.00
The Simply Silicone Bamboo Sorter by Mary Meyer brings eco-conscious playtime front and center with its sustainable bamboo and silicone construction. It fosters fine motor skills and shape recognition in a compact, interactive format perfect for small spaces. Although its size might not appeal to children with a preference for larger toys, we found it to be an enriching tool, offering a blend of durability and intuitive play for an environmentally friendly choice.
The Good
• Made from non-toxic, sustainable materials like bamboo and food-grade silicone.
• Encourages fine motor skills and shape recognition through interactive play.
The Bad
• Compact size may not be suitable for children who prefer larger toys.
Material: Wood,Silicone / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Cognitive Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: ASTM,CPSC / Eco-Friendly: true
Melissa & Doug Wooden Building Blocks
$17.95
Melissa & Doug Wooden Building Blocks fuel creative exploration with their FSC-certified design. Our experience shows they promote motor skills and introduce basic math concepts, despite some potential size-related choking hazards for younger children. Without a storage container, organization can be tricky, but these vibrantly colored blocks remain a staple for imaginative, screen-free play.
The Good
• Made from FSC-certified wood, ensuring eco-friendly and sustainable sourcing.
The Bad
• Some blocks are smaller than expected, posing a potential choking hazard for younger children.
• The set does not include a storage container, making organization challenging.
Material: Wood / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Cognitive Skills,Creativity / Safety Certifications: FSC / Eco-Friendly: true
Enchanted Forest Stacking Blocks by Manhattan Toy
$34.19
Spark your child's imagination with the Enchanted Forest Stacking Blocks by Manhattan Toy, a versatile set that promotes cognitive and motor skills. In our review, these eco-friendly wooden blocks encourage problem-solving and language development, though limited to surface wash only. Their compact nesting ability ensures easy storage and transport, making them perfect for dynamic playtimes. Overall, this playset offers a rich learning experience, ideal for parents seeking both safety and educational value.
The Good
• Encourages motor skills, cause-and-effect learning, problem-solving, cognitive, and language development.
• Blocks nest inside one another for compact storage.
The Bad
• Surface wash only; not suitable for full immersion cleaning.
Material: Wood / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Cognitive Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: EN71,CPSC / Eco-Friendly: true
Sensory Toys: Engaging Baby's Senses
Toys designed to stimulate touch, sight, and sound in a safe and non-toxic way.
AJsupojouet High Contrast Baby Toys
$14.99
Entice your little one's visual senses with the AJsupojouet High Contrast Baby Toys. Our review found these toys engaging with their high-contrast colors, effectively capturing infants' attention for enhanced visual development. While soft and machine washable, some users noticed an initial odd smell and limited sound features. Nevertheless, these versatile pieces attach easily to strollers and cribs, making them a desirable choice for stimulating sensory and cognitive skills on the go.
The Good
• High contrast colors effectively capture infants' attention, aiding in visual development.
• Soft, durable, and machine washable materials ensure safety and easy maintenance.
• Versatile design allows attachment to various baby equipment like strollers and cribs.
The Bad
• Some users report an odd chemical smell upon unboxing.
• Certain components may not stand upright on their own without support.
• Limited auditory features; only select parts produce sounds.
Material: Cotton / Developmental Benefits: Sensory Development,Cognitive Skills / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: false
FIVOENDAR Sensory Balls for Kids
$14.90
FIVOENDAR Sensory Balls for Kids have impressed us with their design geared towards enhancing motor skills and sensory development. These soft, durable silicone balls are easy for babies to grip and play with, encouraging exploration. Although some felt they could be softer, the firm texture ensures they withstand rough play. If you're looking for a versatile toy that supports your child's development throughout various stages, these sensory balls are a resilient and fun option.
The Good
• Soft material is easy for baby to grip, play with happy time!
The Bad
• Some users preferred a softer silicone, the firm texture ensures the balls' longevity.
Material: Silicone / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: false
Magic Years Giraffe
$5.99
The Magic Years Giraffe brings joy to playtime with its cuddly plush design and delightful rendition of 'Twinkle Twinkle Little Star'. In our experience, the musical and visual features captivate infants, though non-replaceable batteries could limit long-term enjoyment. While some units might not function upon arrival, the overall engaging experience it offers makes it a worthwhile option for sensory development.
The Good
• Soft and cuddly plush material.
• Plays 'Twinkle Twinkle Little Star' with accompanying lights.
The Bad
• Non-replaceable batteries limit long-term use.
• Some units may arrive non-functional.
Material: Plastic / Developmental Benefits: Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: false
Little Big Friends Activity Cube
$25.49
Introduce your child to a world of exploration with the Little Big Friends Activity Cube. In our testing, its vibrant textures and engaging designs effectively develop hand-eye coordination and motor skills. The sensory-rich experience, though featuring limited reviews, is crafted from safe materials. This washable cube easily withstands curious hands, offering an engaging experience for adventurous young minds.
The Good
• Encourages hand-eye coordination and motor skills development.
The Bad
• Limited availability of customer reviews.
Material: Cotton / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: EN71 / Eco-Friendly: false
Wooden Toys: Durable & Eco-Friendly Choices
Discover classic wooden toys crafted with sustainable materials and safe finishes.
TOY Life Wooden Baby Cars
$14.98
TOY Life Wooden Baby Cars, crafted from natural wood without resins or pigments, provide a wonderfully eco-friendly choice. Our testing highlights their safety for teething babies, although some users report the cars are smaller than anticipated. Despite this, the durable, wash-friendly design effectively supports motor and sensory skill development, making them an excellent choice for introducing classic play to little ones.
The Good
• Made from natural wood with no resin, pigments, or artificial materials, ensuring safety for teething babies.
The Bad
• Some users found the toy smaller than expected, which may not meet size expectations.
Material: Wood / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Sensory Development / Safety Certifications: / Eco-Friendly: true
Mini Balancing Cactus
$12.00
Encourage your child's focus and fine motor skills with the Mini Balancing Cactus, a compact wooden toy perfect for travel. In our review, its sturdy construction stood out, although some users found the toy challenging to balance. While its small size may pose a choking hazard for younger children, its eco-friendly design and development benefits make it a mindful play option. This toy is ideal for parents looking to engage their child's mind with safe, on-the-go entertainment.
The Good
• Compact size makes it ideal for travel and on-the-go entertainment.
• High-quality, durable wooden construction ensures longevity.
• Encourages development of fine motor skills and hand-eye coordination.
The Bad
• Small pieces may pose a choking hazard for younger children.
• Some users find it difficult to balance, leading to frustration.
• The toy's small size can make handling and assembly challenging for some children.
Material: Wood / Developmental Benefits: Motor Skills,Cognitive Skills / Safety Certifications: ASTM,EN71 / Eco-Friendly: true
Discover More Guides
Topics
Share
More Guides
Latest Articles