Top-Freezer vs. French Door: Which Refrigerator is Right for You in 2025?
July 23, 2025
Overview
Choosing the right refrigerator is essential for any kitchen, and the decision between a top-freezer and a French door model can be daunting. This comprehensive guide breaks down the key differences between these popular refrigerator styles, comparing features like storage capacity, organization, energy efficiency, and overall cost. We'll examine the pros and cons of each type, helping you determine which refrigerator best fits your lifestyle, kitchen layout, and budget in 2025. From ice and water dispensers to smart features, learn what to look for to make an informed decision and find the perfect refrigerator to keep your food fresh and your kitchen stylish.
Our picks
The Best Value: Top-Freezer Refrigerator for 2025: GE Top-Freezer Refrigerator, $1,039.99
The Best for Organization: French Door Refrigerators: MAX™ French Door Refrigerator with InstaView®, $2,999.99
The Best Budget Pick: Affordable Top-Freezer Options: Hotpoint Top Freezer Refrigerator, $764.97
The Most High-Tech: Refrigerators with Smart Features: Forno Moena 36" Inch W. Refrigerator and Freezer with 19.2 cu.ft Total Capacity - French Door Counter Stainless Steel Freestanding Fridge with Ice Maker, Child Safety Lock and Touch Control, $1,597.40
The Best for Minimalists: Top-Freezer's Simple Design: GE Top Freezer Refrigerator, $899.97
Top-Freezer Refrigerators: Pros and Cons
Explore the advantages and disadvantages of traditional top-freezer models in 2025.
7
Listful
Score
GE Top-Freezer Refrigerator
$1,039.99
The GE Top-Freezer Refrigerator provides ample storage and energy efficiency, highlighted by adjustable glass shelves for flexible organization. However, our testing revealed drawbacks such as noisy operation and smaller vegetable bins, which can affect practicality. With a score of 7/10, this model presents a fair price-to-value balance, ideal for those seeking simplicity and dependability over advanced features.
The Good
• Spacious interior with ample storage capacity.
• Equipped with LED lighting for better visibility.
• Adjustable glass shelves for flexible organization.
The Bad
• Some users report the refrigerator operates noisily.
• Vegetable bins are somewhat small and a bit flimsy.
• Bottom shelf on door is narrow and hard to access.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
6.5
Listful
Score
Maytag Top Freezer Refrigerator
$878.97
The Maytag Top Freezer Refrigerator's standout feature, PowerCold®, quickly cools contents, but we found temperature consistency to be a challenge, affecting overall reliability. Although it scores 6.5/10, the unit can unexpectedly freeze or undercool food, offering practicality more for those able to manually monitor settings. Ideal for households needing quick cooling, but with awareness of its temperature fluctuation.
The Good
• The PowerCold® feature quickly chills the refrigerator to help keep everything cool with the touch of a button.
The Bad
• The refrigerator compartment may run colder than expected, potentially freezing fruits and vegetables.
• The freezer compartment runs warmer than ideal, reaching about 4°F instead of the preferred 0°F.
Energy Efficiency: C / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Glass
5.5
Listful
Score
Hotpoint Top Freezer Refrigerator
$764.97
With adjustable wire shelves, the Hotpoint Top Freezer Refrigerator provides flexible storage solutions. However, users should be cautious of possible noise and compressor reliability issues, as reported in our testing. Earning a 5.5/10, this model is best suited for budget-conscious consumers who can deal with potential maintenance considerations while benefiting from its basic, adaptable design.
The Good
• Adjustable wire shelves allow for flexible storage configurations.
The Bad
• Some users report the refrigerator operates noisily.
• Some users report compressor failures within a few months of use.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
5
Listful
Score
Stainless Steel Top Mount Refrigerator
$678.60
This Stainless Steel Top Mount Refrigerator is spacious, offering an 18.2 cu. ft. capacity, and its reversible door feature adds installation flexibility. Yet, our experience shows rust issues and less-effective wire shelving reduces its appeal, leading to a 5/10 score. While the model suits those in need of basic storage, potential compromises on durability and organization may affect long-term satisfaction.
The Good
• The refrigerator offers a spacious 18.2 cu. ft. capacity, providing ample storage for a variety of items.
• The reversible door feature allows for flexible installation to suit different kitchen layouts.
The Bad
• Some users have reported rust developing on the door within a few months of use.
• The wire shelves may cause items to fall over, leading to potential spills and disorganization.
• Several customers have noted that the interior trim and door components are prone to falling off.
Energy Efficiency: A / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Wire
7.5
Listful
Score
Whirlpool Top Freezer Refrigerator
$678.97
The Whirlpool Top Freezer Refrigerator excels with flexible storage and quiet operation, scoring a 7.5/10 in our tests. However, minor drawbacks like warm temperature settings and occasional door issues were observed, requiring manual adjustments for optimal use. Ideal for those prioritizing adaptability and silence in a classic design, this model remains a solid option for 2025.
The Good
• The refrigerator offers flexible storage options, including adjustable shelves, bins, and drawers, enhancing organization.
The Bad
• The recommended temperature settings run slightly warm, requiring manual adjustment for optimal cooling.
• Some customers have reported issues with door functionality, including non-reversible doors and defective components.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
6
Listful
Score
Frigidaire Top Freezer Refrigerator
$658.97
Offering ample storage with adjustable glass shelves, the Frigidaire Top Freezer Refrigerator ensures enough space for household essentials. However, during operation, some users reported noise as a notable drawback. Achieving a 6/10 score, it remains a solid choice for those seeking a reliable, budget-friendly model, ideal for spaces where noise can be overlooked in favor of spaciousness.
The Good
• The refrigerator offers ample storage space with adjustable glass shelves for flexible organization.
The Bad
• Some users have reported that the refrigerator can be noisy during operation.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Glass
5.5
Listful
Score
Kenmore Stainless Steel Refrigerator
$450.00
For those prioritizing budget over bells and whistles, the Kenmore Stainless Steel Refrigerator comes at a wallet-friendly $450 but our testing gave it a 5.5/10 due to reliability issues. While it features adjustable glass shelves for flexible storage, users reported recurring problems with the ice maker and cooling system. Its lack of a dispenser and smart features places it more in the basic utility category than innovation.
The Good
• Adjustable glass shelves allow for flexible storage configurations.
The Bad
• Some users reported issues with the ice maker and water filter malfunctioning.
• The refrigerator stopped cooling properly after a short period.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
6.5
Listful
Score
GE Top Freezer Refrigerator
$899.97
The GE Top Freezer Refrigerator offers decent value with a spacious interior and energy-efficient design, scoring 6.5/10 in our tests. Despite a practical configuration, some exterior quality issues such as smudging and surface defects were noted. Ideal for those who prefer traditional styling and simplicity, this model provides an affordable and straightforward solution for basic needs.
The Good
• Spacious interior with well-designed shelving and drawers.
The Bad
• Stainless steel exterior shows smudges easily.
• Some units reported to have scratches and blisters upon delivery.
Energy Efficiency: B / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
6.5
Listful
Score
Frigidaire Top Freezer Refrigerator
$778.97
The Frigidaire Top Freezer Refrigerator is a good value pick, especially with its EvenTemp™ Cooling System and 20 cu. ft. capacity fitting into a standard 18 cu. ft. cutout. With a score of 6.5/10, it does lack built-in perks like ice dispensers, making it competitive for basic needs. This model is suitable for those looking for a traditional but efficient addition to accommodate essential storage.
The Good
• Spacious 20 cu. ft. capacity fits in standard 18 cu. ft. fridge cutout.
• EvenTemp™ Cooling System prevents warm spots and unwanted freezing.
• Humidity-controlled crisper drawers keep produce fresher longer.
The Bad
• Optional ice maker is sold separately.
• No built-in water or ice dispenser.
• Lacks smart features like WiFi connectivity.
Energy Efficiency: A++ / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
6
Listful
Score
Top Freezer Refrigerator
$648.00
Perfect for compact spaces, this Top Freezer Refrigerator caters to essential needs with its ENERGY STAR efficiency and flexible adjustable shelves. Earning a 6/10 score, it’s an apt choice for those embracing simplicity. While devoid of ice-making capabilities, it compensates with energy savings, though our experience shows the condenser’s design may cause sidewalls to feel warm, requiring thoughtful placement for ventilation. Ideal for budget-conscious buyers prioritizing efficiency over frills.
The Good
• Compact size suitable for small spaces.
• Energy-efficient with ENERGY STAR certification.
• Adjustable glass shelves for flexible storage.
The Bad
• No built-in ice maker.
• Side walls can become hot due to hot wall condenser design.
• Requires significant clearance for proper ventilation.
Energy Efficiency: A++ / Dispenser Type: None / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
French Door Refrigerators: Benefits to Know
Discover the features and benefits that make French door refrigerators a popular choice.
9.5
Listful
Score
MAX™ French Door Refrigerator with InstaView®
$2,999.99
In our review, the MAX™ French Door Refrigerator with InstaView® shines as a top-rated choice with its cutting-edge features. Remote control through ThinQ® Technology and a unique window design allow you to see contents without opening the door. Despite its impressive 9.5/10 score, its substantial size and higher cost might deter those with limited space or budget. This refrigerator is perfect for tech-savvy users seeking luxury and functionality in 2025.
The Good
• Offers four types of ice: cubed, crushed, mini cubed, and slow-melting round Craft Ice™.
• Features a Mirror InstaView® window that allows users to see inside without opening the door.
• Equipped with ThinQ® Technology for remote control and monitoring via smartphone.
The Bad
• The large 30.7 cu. ft. capacity may require significant kitchen space.
• Premium features contribute to a higher price point compared to basic models.
• Advanced features may have a learning curve for users unfamiliar with smart appliances.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: true / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
8
Listful
Score
Forno Moena 36" Inch W. Refrigerator and Freezer with 19.2 cu.ft Total Capacity - French Door Counter Stainless Steel Freestanding Fridge with Ice Maker, Child Safety Lock and Touch Control
$1,597.40
Ideal for modern homes, the Forno Moena offers 19.2 cu.ft. of space, perfect for larger families. While it boasts an efficient ice maker and high-quality LED lighting, the absence of a water dispenser and freezer organization lowers its ranking to 8/10 in our guide. For those seeking ample capacity without needing water at-the-ready, it remains an efficient and reliable choice.
The Good
• The refrigerator offers a spacious 19.2 cu.ft. capacity, with 12.1 cu.ft. for fresh food and 7.1 cu.ft. for the freezer.
• It includes an ice maker with a 4.3 L capacity, providing a steady supply of ice.
• The refrigerator features high-efficiency LED lighting, ensuring uniform illumination and preventing food spoilage.
The Bad
• The refrigerator lacks a water dispenser, which may be a drawback for some users.
• The freezer section does not include shelves, which might limit organization options.
• The refrigerator does not have adjustable door storage, potentially affecting flexibility in storing items.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: Ice / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
8.5
Listful
Score
Samsung Bespoke French Door Refrigerator
$3,239.99
The Samsung Bespoke French Door Refrigerator impresses with customizable door panels and a concealed Beverage Center, though its premium price and initial ice taste affected some users in our testing. With a commendable 8.5/10 score, this model is perfect for design-savvy users seeking a customizable, feature-rich appliance without minding a higher upfront investment.
The Good
• Offers customizable door panels in various colors and finishes.
• Features a concealed Beverage Center with water dispenser and AutoFill Water Pitcher.
• Equipped with a Dual Ice Maker providing cubed ice and Ice Bites.
The Bad
• Custom-color panels are a separate purchase, increasing overall cost.
• The refrigerator's depth may cause it to protrude beyond standard countertops.
• Initial ice production may have an off taste and limited quantity.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: true / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
8
Listful
Score
LG French Door Smart Refrigerator
$1,699.99
In our review, the LG French Door Smart Refrigerator earned an 8/10 for its smart functionality and energy efficiency, although it could be a bit cumbersome in smaller kitchens. The Slim SpacePlus® Ice System enables more shelf space, and consistent cooling helps maintain food quality. However, with a depth of 36.25 inches and a weight of 292 lbs, it may not be ideal for compact layouts or frequent movers.
The Good
• The Slim SpacePlus® Ice System provides more shelf space and allows even more space for door bins.
• Blasts of cool air reach all areas of the refrigerator—including the door—to help maintain consistent temperatures from top to bottom.
• The LG ThinQ® app helps you manage all of your LG Smart appliances and more to make your everyday a little easier and keep your home running smarter.
The Bad
• The refrigerator's depth with handles is 36.25 inches, which may protrude in smaller kitchens.
• The ice storage capacity is 2.5 lbs, which might be insufficient for larger households.
• The refrigerator's weight is 292 lbs, making it challenging to move without assistance.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: true / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
9
Listful
Score
ZLINE 36 in. Black Stainless Refrigerator
$3,419.96
The ZLINE 36 in. Black Stainless Refrigerator scores a strong 9/10 for its spacious design and dual ice makers. Its 28.9 cu. ft capacity and fingerprint-resistant finish make it a stylish yet practical choice. Users should note the noisy ice maker and heavy doors, which might be an inconvenience. Despite these small concerns, this refrigerator stands out for its luxurious appearance and consistent performance.
The Good
• The refrigerator offers a spacious 28.9 cu. ft. capacity, providing ample storage for groceries.
• The fingerprint-resistant black stainless steel finish minimizes cleaning efforts.
• Dual ice makers produce nearly 7 pounds of ice daily, ensuring a steady supply.
The Bad
• Some users have reported that the ice maker can be noisy during operation.
• The refrigerator's doors can feel heavy, which might be inconvenient for some users.
• The shelves could be more adjustable to accommodate various item sizes.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
7.5
Listful
Score
GE Profile French Door Smart Refrigerator
$2,399.00
With a score of 7.5/10, the GE Profile French Door Smart Refrigerator offers a mix of tech-savvy elements and functional design. The SmartHQ app integration and spacious interior give it an edge, though the freezer drawer’s stiffness and the confusing Keurig system were shortcomings. It's a solid choice for those who prioritize smart capabilities and innovative features while accommodating constraints in space and ease of use.
The Good
• The refrigerator features a spacious interior with bright LED lighting, enhancing visibility and storage capacity.
• The integrated water pitcher is convenient and automatically refills, providing chilled, filtered water.
• The SmartHQ app integration allows for remote monitoring and control of the refrigerator settings.
The Bad
• The freezer drawer can be difficult to open and may wobble during use.
• The Keurig brewing system is unintuitive and can cause coffee splatters during operation.
• The refrigerator compartment is smaller than average for a French-door fridge, limiting storage space.
Energy Efficiency: A++ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: true / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
7
Listful
Score
KitchenAid French Door Refrigerator
$2,599.99
Earning a score of 7/10, the KitchenAid French Door Refrigerator is a stylish addition with a spacious 27 cu. ft. capacity. Its PrintShield finish adds sophistication, but a noisy ice maker might disturb serene settings. While offering excellent storage flexibility, its varying depth compared to standard cabinetry could impact kitchen coherence, making it a good fit for open layouts or a premium stand-alone installation.
The Good
• The refrigerator offers a spacious 27 cu. ft. capacity, providing ample storage for groceries.
• The PrintShield finish resists fingerprints, maintaining a clean exterior appearance.
• The ice maker is located in the refrigerator door, freeing up shelf space inside.
The Bad
• The ice maker can be noisy during operation, which may be disruptive in quiet environments.
• The refrigerator's depth may protrude beyond standard cabinetry, affecting kitchen aesthetics.
• The water filter requires regular replacement, adding to maintenance costs over time.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
6
Listful
Score
ZLINE French Door Refrigerator
$11,219.48
While the ZLINE French Door Refrigerator offers premium features with a large 28.9 cu. ft. capacity and dual ice makers, its score of 6/10 reflects the hefty price tag and space limitations. Ideal for users requiring high ice production, this model excels in convenience but the $11,219.48 cost and heavy weight make it less practical for budget-conscious or compact kitchen spaces.
The Good
• The refrigerator offers a spacious 28.9 cu. ft. capacity, providing ample storage for large households.
• The external water and ice dispenser accommodates containers up to 10 inches tall, enhancing convenience.
• The refrigerator features dual ice makers, producing nearly 7 pounds of ice daily, suitable for high-demand use.
The Bad
• The refrigerator's price point of $11,219.48 may be prohibitive for budget-conscious consumers.
• The unit's weight of 348 lbs may complicate installation and require additional assistance.
• The refrigerator's depth of 34 inches may protrude in smaller kitchens, affecting space efficiency.
Energy Efficiency: A++ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
7
Listful
Score
Whirlpool French Door Refrigerator
$1,999.99
The Whirlpool French Door Refrigerator strikes a balance between spaciousness and affordability, scoring a 7/10 for practicality. It may lack smart features but offers flexible storage and energy efficiency, with its appealing fingerprint-resistant exterior. Although the ice maker is occasionally noisy, this model is suitable for families looking for a reliable option without the complications of advanced features.
The Good
• Spacious interior with adjustable shelves and bins for flexible storage.
• Fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish helps maintain a clean appearance.
• Energy Star certified for efficient energy consumption.
The Bad
• Ice maker can be noisy during operation.
• Water dispenser may drip occasionally.
• Lacks smart features like Wi-Fi connectivity.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: false / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
8.5
Listful
Score
LG LRFVS3006S
$3,954.00
In our review, the LG LRFVS3006S shines with an impressive 8.5/10 score, thanks to its expansive 30 cu. ft. capacity and the unique InstaView® Door-in-Door® feature that offers convenient access to your favorites. Ideal for larger households, this refrigerator also boasts Craft Ice™ for perfect, slow-melting spheres. However, its energy consumption and protruding depth might not suit smaller kitchens or eco-conscious buyers, but it remains a top contender for those seeking luxury and functionality.
The Good
• The refrigerator offers a spacious 30 cu. ft. capacity, allowing ample storage for groceries.
• The InstaView® Door-in-Door® feature provides easy access to frequently used items without opening the main door.
• The refrigerator includes dual ice makers, including a Craft Ice™ maker for slow-melting ice spheres.
The Bad
• The refrigerator's depth with handles is 36.63 inches, which may protrude beyond standard countertops.
• The refrigerator consumes 730 kWh/year, which may be higher than some energy-efficient models.
• The refrigerator's weight of 342 lbs. may require assistance during installation.
Energy Efficiency: A+ / Dispenser Type: Water and Ice / Smart Features: true / Shelf Configuration: Adjustable
Share
More Guides
Latest Articles