Top-Rated Shaving Creams for a Close and Comfortable Shave 2025
July 18, 2025
Overview
Achieve your smoothest shave yet with our top-rated shaving creams for 2025. We've meticulously researched and reviewed the best shaving creams on the market, focusing on performance, skin protection, and overall comfort. From luxurious formulas with rich scents to options specifically designed for sensitive skin, discover the perfect shaving cream to elevate your daily grooming routine and experience a close, comfortable shave every time. Whether you're looking to minimize irritation or achieve the perfect glide, find your ideal shaving cream in our ultimate guide.
Our picks
The Most Luxurious Shaving Cream Experience: Supreme Cream Shave Lather, $30.00
The Best Budget-Friendly Shaving Cream Option: Gillette Foamy Sensitive Shave Foam, $3.29
The Best Shaving Cream for a Smooth and Comfortable Shave: THAYERS Gentlemen's Shave Cream, $10.90
Best Shaving Creams for Sensitive Skin
Gentle formulas designed to minimize irritation and redness for sensitive skin types.
6
Listful
Score
Gillette Foamy Sensitive Shave Foam
$3.29
Gillette Foamy Sensitive Shave Foam, scored at 6/10, is a budget-friendly choice for those seeking a thick, creamy lather without breaking the bank. While it offers good glide for a close shave, some users with sensitive skin may experience irritation due to its fragrant formula. We recommend trying it if you’re looking for affordability, but be cautious if you're sensitive to scent.
The Good
• Provides a thick, extra rich, creamy lather for a close, comfortable shave.
The Bad
• Contains fragrance, which may cause irritation for some users with sensitive skin.
• Some users report that the new formula has a strong, unpleasant scent.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
7
Listful
Score
Nivea Men Sensitive Shaving Gel
$4.79
Nivea Men Sensitive Shaving Gel, achieving a 7/10 rating, provides sensitive skin with a smooth shave enriched with Vitamin E and Chamomile. Though some users report dispenser issues, the gel effectively reduces irritation. It's an excellent choice for those looking for an affordable, gentle shave if potential usability concerns are not a dealbreaker.
The Good
• Enriched with Vitamin E, Chamomile, and Witch Hazel extracts to care for the skin while shaving.
• Provides a smooth, comfortable shave without irritation, making it suitable for sensitive skin.
The Bad
• Some users report issues with the dispenser, such as the can running out of air while still full.
• The gel may solidify over time, rendering the product unusable before it's fully consumed.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
9
Listful
Score
Pacific Shaving Company Shea Butter Shave Cream
$9.99
Our top-rated choice, Pacific Shaving Company's Shea Butter Shave Cream, scored a remarkable 9/10 for its exceptional performance and affordability. Perfect for sensitive skin, it provides a smooth, few-irritation shave, with just a little product going a long way. Though some find the consistency thin, its overall value, combined with natural ingredients, is unmatched.
The Good
• Provides a smooth shave with minimal irritation, making it suitable for sensitive skin.
• A small amount goes a long way, offering good value for the price.
• Contains natural ingredients like shea butter and vitamin E, beneficial for skin health.
The Bad
• Some users find the consistency too thin, leading to a less substantial lather.
• The product may dry out quickly during shaving, requiring reapplication.
• A few users report that it can clog razors if too much product is used.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Unscented
7.5
Listful
Score
SUPPLY Ultra Lather Shaving Cream
$14.40
SUPPLY Ultra Lather Shaving Cream, earning a respectable 7.5/10, excels with its rich, thick lather and natural ingredients like Aloe Vera and Shea Butter, making it a top pick for sensitive skin. Though some users find the consistency akin to a soft soap, requiring a shaving brush, it still provides an irritation-free shave. Despite its higher price, the various scent options, including fragrance-free, cater to different preferences.
The Good
• Creates a rich, thick lather that ensures a smooth, irritation-free shave.
• Contains natural ingredients like Aloe-Vera, Jojoba Oil, and Shea Butter, making it suitable for sensitive skin.
• Available in various scents, including fragrance-free options, catering to different preferences.
The Bad
• Some users find the consistency more like a soft soap or 'croap', which may require adjustment in usage.
• Priced higher than some other shaving creams, which might be a consideration for budget-conscious buyers.
• A few users reported difficulty in achieving the desired lather without using a shaving brush.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Natural
6
Listful
Score
Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel
$4.47
Suffering from razor burn and irritation? Aveeno's fragrance-free shave gel is a game-changer for sensitive skin. This dermatologist-recommended formula, infused with oat and vitamin E, soothes as it lubricates, delivering a close, comfortable shave while minimizing bumps and redness. Finally, enjoy a smooth, irritation-free experience, perfect for your sensitive skin needs.
The Good
• Contains oat and vitamin E to soothe dry skin and help prevent razor bumps.
The Bad
• Some users report that it can dry the skin after a few hours.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Unscented
Luxury Shaving Creams with Exceptional Scents
Indulge in premium shaving creams featuring rich fragrances for a luxurious experience.
8
Listful
Score
Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream
$17.99
Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel, scoring 6/10, stands out with its soothing oat and vitamin E formulation, ideal for sensitive skin in need of gentle care. While it's excellent at preventing razor bumps and irritation, some users report skin dryness post-shave. If you're seeking a dependable, unscented option for minimizing bumps and redness, Aveeno offers a smooth yet occasionally drying shaving experience.
The Good
• Produces a rich and luxurious lather that enhances the shaving experience.
• A small amount of cream is sufficient for a full shave, making it cost-effective.
• The cream's consistency allows for easy application and quick lathering.
The Bad
• Some users find the sandalwood scent to be overpowering or not true to traditional sandalwood.
• Individuals with sensitive skin may experience a slight burning sensation during use.
• Some users report that the cream can be messy to clean up after shaving.
Skin Type Compatibility: Normal / Irritation Reduction: false / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
6
Listful
Score
Sandalwood Shaving Cream
$38.00
Our premium choice, the Sandalwood Shaving Cream from Truefitt & Hill, boasts a rich, luxurious lather that softens skin with each shave. Earning a 6/10 score, it's a splurge at $38, though its unique, aromatic sandalwood scent appeals to many. It requires more water and care for optimal lather, but if you're after an indulgent sensory experience, this might be the ultimate choice despite its high price.
The Good
• Produces a rich, luxurious lather that enhances the shaving experience.
• The sandalwood scent is unique and not overpowering, appealing to many users.
• The cream's moisturizing properties leave the skin feeling supple and hydrated post-shave.
The Bad
• Some users find the price point to be steep compared to other shaving creams.
• The scent may linger on shaving brushes, requiring extra cleaning to remove.
• The cream's consistency may require more water than usual to achieve optimal lather.
Skin Type Compatibility: Normal / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
6.5
Listful
Score
Sandalwood Shaving Cream
$35.00
The Art of Shaving's Sandalwood Shaving Cream, scoring 6.5/10, offers a rich, protective lather and a warm, masculine aroma, perfect for sensitive skin comfort. While the sandalwood scent is captivating for some, others find it too overpowering, and its price might be a concern. Ideal for those seeking rich hydration and a luxurious shave, just be prepared for possible razor residue cleanup.
The Good
• Creates a rich, foamy lather that protects the skin from irritation and helps hydrate and soften beard hair.
• Contains a high concentration of glycerin to provide hydration during the shave.
• Made with 100% sustainably sourced Sandalwood essential oil to help nourish dry skin and produce a warm, masculine aroma.
The Bad
• Some users find the sandalwood scent to be overpowering.
• Priced higher than some other shaving creams on the market.
• May leave residue on razors, requiring extra cleaning.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
Shaving Creams for a Close, Comfortable Shave
Formulas that provide excellent glide and help achieve the closest possible shave.
8
Listful
Score
Supreme Cream Shave Lather
$30.00
Supreme Cream Shave Lather delivers a smooth, irritation-free shaving experience, earning it an 8/10 score despite its higher price. Formulated with Macadamia Nut and Jojoba Oils, it deeply moisturizes and minimizes irritation, making it ideal for sensitive skin. Some may find lathering tricky, but if you seek luxurious skin protection, this cream is a top choice despite its cost.
The Good
• Provides excellent lubrication for a smooth shave.
• Contains moisturizing ingredients like Macadamia Nut Oil and Jojoba Oil.
The Bad
• Some users find it hard to lather properly.
• Higher price point compared to other shaving creams.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Natural
6.5
Listful
Score
CREMO Palo Santo Shaving Foam
$34.99
The CREMO Palo Santo Shaving Foam offers an inviting fragrance and a smooth shave, scoring 6.5/10 in our review. While its creamy texture ensures no nicks or cuts, some users might find it too thick and pricey. Ideal for normal skin, it still delivers appealing results, but pricing and texture might deter some.
The Good
• Provides a smooth shave with no cuts or irritation.
The Bad
• Some users find the texture too thick and difficult to clean.
• The product is considered overpriced by some customers.
Skin Type Compatibility: Normal / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
8.5
Listful
Score
Harry's Foaming Shave Gel
$11.49
In our testing, Harry's Foaming Shave Gel scored 8.5/10, offering a well-rounded shave with rich lather and soothing aloe vera. With a refreshing and subtle scent, it's a perfect choice for sensitive skin, though some might find it thicker than desired. Despite being slightly pricier, its performance makes it a favored option for many.
The Good
• Provides a rich, creamy lather that ensures a smooth glide for the razor.
• Enriched with aloe vera and cucumber extracts to moisturize and reduce irritation.
• Subtle, clean scent that is refreshing and not overpowering.
The Bad
• Some users may find the foam too thick, potentially prolonging the shaving process.
• Limited fragrance options may not cater to everyone's personal preferences.
• The product may be more expensive compared to other shaving gels.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
7
Listful
Score
White Eagle Shave Cream
$14.00
White Eagle Shave Cream scores 7/10 for its invigorating, cooling sensation and suitability for sensitive skin. Its menthol and camphor blend offers a refreshing experience, though the thick consistency may lead to razor clogging issues. If a cooling shave is your priority, this product is worth considering despite its minor drawbacks.
The Good
• Provides a refreshing, cooling sensation that invigorates the skin during and after the shave.
• Excellent for sensitive skin, helping to reduce irritation.
• The menthol and camphor provide an invigorating cooling effect, enhancing the shaving experience.
The Bad
• The thick consistency may clog razors, making cleaning more difficult.
• The cream's thickness can make rinsing off more challenging compared to lighter foams or gels.
• Some users may find the unscented formula lacking a desired fragrance.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Unscented
7
Listful
Score
MARLOWE. No. 141 Shave Cream
$17.00
MARLOWE. No. 141 Shave Cream brings an impressive composition, scoring 7/10 with its hydrating, natural ingredients like shea butter. While some users report thin consistency, requiring reapplication, its eco-friendly approach makes it a worthy pick for those with sensitive skin. Despite minor drawbacks, it remains a solid choice in our guide.
The Good
• Contains natural ingredients like shea butter and coconut oil that deeply hydrate the skin.
• Free of parabens and phthalates, making it suitable for sensitive skin.
The Bad
• Some users find the cream's consistency too thin, requiring reapplication during shaving.
• May leave a soapy film on the skin post-shave, which some users find unpleasant.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Natural
6.5
Listful
Score
THAYERS Gentlemen's Shave Cream
$10.90
THAYERS Gentlemen's Shave Cream scored a 6.5/10, notable for its excellent cushion and lubrication thanks to natural moisturizers. However, it doesn't create a thick lather, and some may not favor the woody, medicinal scent. Despite its challenges with shaving brushes, this cream leaves sensitive skin feeling refreshed and protected, appealing to those who prioritize comfort over lather density.
The Good
• Provides excellent cushion and lubrication for a comfortable shave.
• Contains natural moisturizers that leave skin feeling refreshed post-shave.
• Features a mild, woody scent that is generally inoffensive.
The Bad
• Does not produce a thick lather, which may not appeal to all users.
• Some users report the scent as medicinal or unappealing.
• The cream's consistency may not work well with shaving brushes.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Natural
5.5
Listful
Score
Bulldog Original Shave Gel
$7.21
Bulldog Original Shave Gel combines aloe vera and green tea to provide hydration and soothing benefits, earning a 5.5/10 in our review. The clear gel may make it tricky to see shaved areas, but it's perfect for daily use across all skin types. If you enjoy a subtly mentholated, moisturized shave and don't mind the application quirks, Bulldog could offer great value at only $7.21.
The Good
• Contains natural ingredients like aloe vera and green tea, providing hydration and soothing properties.
The Bad
• The clear gel can make it difficult to see areas already shaved, potentially leading to missed spots.
• Some users may find the menthol cooling effect too mild for their preference.
Skin Type Compatibility: Normal / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Natural
7.5
Listful
Score
Proraso Green Shaving Cream
$20.00
Proraso Green Shaving Cream transports you to an Italian barbershop with its rich, concentrated formula. In our review, we noted its refreshing eucalyptus and menthol blend provides excellent razor glide with a cooling sensation. Scored at 7.5/10, it offers good value, but be mindful of its strong scent and potential irritation for sensitive skin. While some might be put off by its parabens, if menthol freshness is your preference, this cream remains a classic choice.
The Good
• Produces a rich, slick lather that enhances razor glide.
• Provides a refreshing cooling sensation due to menthol content.
• Affordable price point for the quality offered.
The Bad
• The strong menthol scent may not appeal to everyone.
• Some users with sensitive skin report irritation from menthol.
• Contains parabens, which some users prefer to avoid.
Skin Type Compatibility: Normal / Irritation Reduction: false / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
Shaving Creams That Reduce Razor Burn
Products specifically formulated to combat and prevent razor burn and irritation.
8
Listful
Score
Cooling Shave Cream
$8.99
Cooling Shave Cream, celebrated for its unique cooling effect, scored 8/10 in our reviews. The menthol-infused formula ensures a slick, irritation-free shave while providing a refreshing sensation. Despite its strong scent, this cream offers a delightful shave for those who crave a chill with their routine.
The Good
• Provides a refreshing cooling sensation during and after shaving.
• Offers excellent slickness, allowing the razor to glide smoothly over the skin.
• Suitable for sensitive skin, reducing irritation and razor burn.
The Bad
• Does not produce a traditional lather, which may be off-putting for some users.
• The strong menthol scent might be overwhelming for certain individuals.
• Some users report that the cooling effect can be too intense, causing discomfort.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
6.5
Listful
Score
Original Shave Cream
$8.99
Original Shave Cream, priced at just $8.99, offers an exceptionally slick surface, making it a cost-effective choice for reducing nicks and irritation during shaving. In our review, it scored 6.5/10, reflecting its quick-drying nature and distinct scent, which some users may find polarizing. Ideal for those with normal skin, this cream provides a smooth shave if you're quick with the razor, though the fragrance might not be for everyone.
The Good
• Provides an exceptionally slick surface for shaving, reducing nicks and irritation.
The Bad
• Dries quickly, requiring prompt shaving to prevent the cream from drying on the skin.
• Some users find the scent to be industrial or unpleasant.
Skin Type Compatibility: Normal / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: false / Fragrance: Fragrant
7
Listful
Score
C.O. Bigelow Shaving Cream
$9.95
C.O. Bigelow Shaving Cream impresses with a 7/10 score, offering a quick, creamy lather and a refreshing eucalyptus and menthol cooling sensation. Our experience shows it's suitable for various skin types, even sensitive ones, though its inclusion of SLS might irritate some users. If the soothing and invigorating shave this cream provides appeals to you, be mindful of its potential post-shave dryness and packaging quirks.
The Good
• Creates a rich, creamy lather quickly, enhancing the shaving experience.
• Infused with eucalyptus and menthol, providing a refreshing, cooling sensation during shaving.
• Suitable for various skin types, including sensitive skin, due to its soothing ingredients.
The Bad
• Contains Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS), which may irritate sensitive skin.
• The metal tube packaging can become misshapen with use, affecting aesthetics.
• Some users report skin dryness post-shave, possibly due to certain ingredients.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
7
Listful
Score
Gillette Series Soothing Shaving Gel
$5.99
For those battling post-shave irritation, Gillette Series Soothing Shaving Gel, rated 7/10, is a budget-friendly remedy. Its aloe vera-infused formula offers a calming effect, allowing your razor to glide effortlessly while reducing cuts and burns. During our review, we found its pleasant scent and easy rinse-off appealing, though the bulky packaging could be inconvenient for travelers. Comparable to Nivea Men Sensitive Gel, it's perfect for a straightforward and irritation-free shave.
The Good
• Contains aloe vera, providing a cooling and calming effect that reduces irritation during and after shaving.
• Creates a rich lather that allows razors to glide smoothly, helping prevent cuts and razor burns.
• The scent is light and fresh, and the formula rinses off easily without leaving a sticky residue.
The Bad
• The canister is easy to use, but its size may be inconvenient for travel purposes.
• Some users may find the strong men's scent less appealing or too overpowering.
• The packaging is a little big and hard to travel with, which can be inconvenient for frequent travelers.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
Shaving Cream for the Perfect Glide
Explore creams specifically designed for smooth and effortless razor gliding.
7.5
Listful
Score
Moisturizing Shave Cream
$34.00
Moisturizing Shave Cream, rated 7.5/10, stands out with its chemical-free formula and skin-soothing benefits. Ideal for sensitive skin, it combines olive oil and aloe for a smooth shave, free of phthalates and parabens. Though its cost may be on the higher side, its skin-friendly attributes offer compelling value in our guide.
The Good
• Contains olive oil and aloe to moisturize and soothe the skin during shaving.
• Free of phthalates, parabens, silicones, and artificial color or fragrance, making it suitable for sensitive skin.
The Bad
• Priced at $34.00 for a 5.0 oz size, which may be considered expensive compared to other shaving creams.
Skin Type Compatibility: Sensitive / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Natural
7
Listful
Score
Skintimate Shave Gel
$3.99
Skintimate Shave Gel provides a rich, creamy lather at an affordable $3.99, scoring 7/10 in our reviews. Excellent for dry skin, its six moisturizers, like olive butter and vitamin E, ensure a hydrated and soft post-shave feel. The fragrance may not suit everyone, and while some might prefer more lather, this gel excels in providing a close, comfortable shave with great glide.
The Good
• Provides a rich, creamy lather that enhances razor glide for a close shave.
• Contains six moisturizers, including olive butter and vitamin E, to hydrate and soften dry skin.
The Bad
• Some users may find the fragrance too strong or not to their liking.
• The gel may not lather as much as some users prefer.
Skin Type Compatibility: Dry / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
6.5
Listful
Score
Flamingo Foaming Shave Gel
$5.99
Flamingo Foaming Shave Gel, available at Target for $5.99, provides a soothing shave thanks to its aloe vera-infused formula that minimizes irritation, leaving skin comfortable and soft. With a score of 6.5/10, we found the gel's lather rich but noted users occasionally report it runs during application. Despite containing parabens, it offers solid performance for normal skin types, ensuring a slick shave if you can look past its minor drawbacks.
The Good
• The gel provides a rich, comfortable lather, ensuring a close shave without causing unnecessary friction against the skin.
• The product is infused with aloe vera, which helps soothe and moisturize the skin during shaving, reducing irritation and leaving it soft and smooth.
The Bad
• Some users have reported that the shaving gel can sometimes run during application, which might require more effort to keep the lather stable.
• The product contains parabens, which are preservatives that have been linked to various health concerns, although more research is needed to establish definitive proof.
Skin Type Compatibility: Normal / Irritation Reduction: true / Moisturizing Properties: true / Fragrance: Fragrant
Share
More Guides
Latest Articles